Luigi's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Pennsylvania

We have been going to Luigi's for pizza for more years than I care to count. It had always been our go to pizza place. But the last year or so haven't been so good. Three times before today we had ordered their pizza and every time it was over done. Still edible but not too good. We kept making excuses for them but today was the final straw. When we opened the box, there were black bubbles of cheese on the top. The crust was dark, dark brown - edges and bottom. I tried to eat a couple of pieces but had to quit because my jaw was hurting from trying to chew it. They couldn't have missed the black cheese on top but they boxed it anyway. I've been reading all of the great reviews and can only come to one or two conclusions. 1. They have our name on there wall with a memo to always give us the garbage. Or 2. When people get lousy pizza they can't be bothered to complain. Either way, we will never be going back. $29 for garbage! P.S. I had to give them 1 star so I could post this. They don't deserve...

BEST pizza in the valley - NO competition. (and by far my favorite pizza on the planet) The sauce contains green peppers- and the toppings are "REAL". For example: sausage- large pieces of seasoned sausage, as opposed to those strange little pebbles found on every other pizza in the area. Ordering is simple: They only sell ONE size, a medium-round. Price is reasonable, especially when compared to chains like Pizza Hut. My sole complaint is they're CASH ONLY. If you're looking for a delicious pizza in the valley, you can't go wrong with Luigis- just make sure you hit up an...

I have been going to Luigi’s for pizza since they were at the Hickory Plaza and the lady who manages/owns the place was too young to buy a beer. Today the pizza is every bit as good, if you can get it. Seems that they only prepare enough dough for X amount of pizzas on a given night, and if they have a busy night they could be closed by 6:00. They even have the audacity to be rude when you call and order, warning you about being there before their ever changing closing time. Straight up lost a life time customer,...