The Mad Sicilian — Restaurant in Petaluma

Let me start with the fact that the pizza tasted great and made with quality ingredients but the reason I give the lowest score is because of the final bill of $75 for a large pizza and two beers. As we were traveling through town during a bicycle tour in the region, we thought a pizza from a local business would be the best way to support the community and our budget. The online menu advertises a large pizza for less than $30, which is reasonable these days. The problem comes when you ask for half and half, which added an additional $22 in our case yet wasn’t disclosed to us before we got the bill. While the owner mentioned that the sauces might mix, we were never warned about the price hike ~70%. Second surprise is the dine-in fee of $9, which wasn’t advertised either. So add everything up plus taxes and you get to the $75 surprise on the bill. I later called the owner to discuss this, yet he insisted that it was correct. While I appreciate his offer for a discount or commercial gesture next time we stop by, I still don’t think it’s a proper way to do business. Takeaway for me is, be sure to asked for the final price and clear if there’s a dine-in fee before I order from a local business. I’m all for supporting my local economy but not if that means paying almost...

I have ordered from here 3 times. Each time I got a deep dish and chocolate mousse. The first time it was one of the best pizza's I have ever had and the dessert was free and really good. I thought it was Better than old Chicago. The second time the pizza was horrible, but the dessert was good. Got it again last night and it was average at best, but also tried the margarita pizza and that was really good. The chocolate mousse was disgusting. I assume they make a bunch of them in the beginning of the week and if they don’t sell out they sell them the next day. Ours tasted like it was expired, and if it wasn’t expired then one of the ingredients was. It’s really disappointing since the first experience was so good. I also noticed our first experience was when they first opened this restaurant and the food was made by the owner’s and it was amazing. The other two times the food was made by younger staff and tasted like a completely different restaurant. Everyone there is super friendly, and I really hope they can get back to tasting like our first experience, if they do I know they will be known as the best pizza...

I ordered a vegetarian pizza, it cost be more than $35.00. I am vegetarian due to religious purposes. Turns out they dropped couple pieces of pepperoni in my pizza!!! I didn't realize at first when I opened the pizza. I called the place to resolve the issue. At this point I didn't wanna go back to them or get another pizza from them because I had lost my trust. They didn't just mess up my order but hurt my religious morals. I even told the lady when placing the order about my strict diet and recommended them to use a clean cutter too. But even though they couldn't handle my order properly!!!! The lady at the store was offering me another pizza and other options to fix the mistake. But She didn't understand I didn't want any food from them anymore. I asked for my refund and she argued with me to the point I was crying and she hung up the phone on me. I was emotionally hurt and already broken from the inside and her aggressive attitude lead me to cry. Highly don't recommend! Don't trust this place with your food especially if you have allergies or any kind of strict diet! Plus they have a very poor...