Ultimate Pastry Shop — Restaurant in Sewickley

I was recently introduced to The Ultimate Pastry Shop when a student brought in a Kings Cake for class. IT WAS AMAZING! We ate the entire thing between four people. I took a chance by ordering a birthday cake in March and it was such a hit with the entire family it has now become our go to for all family cakes movong forward. I called on a Wednesday to place an order for the upcoming Saturday. They were happy to make a dinosaur cake which I left the icing flavor up to them to best accommodate my 3 year olds request for dinosaurs. They even asked me if I wanted realistic or cartoon type! They are top notch. The cake tastes as good as it looks. I am looking forward to placing orders this coming holiday season. One thing, due to the pandemic, they have limited hours and selection. Best...

They Saved the Day!

We had a last-minute emergency the morning of my son’s birthday party (today) — our original cake plans fell through, and we were scrambling with just a few hours to go. I called The Ultimate Pastry Shop in a panic, and they absolutely saved the day.

Not only were they kind, understanding, and quick to help, but the cake they provided was beautiful, perfectly decorated, and absolutely delicious. Everyone at the party raved about it — kids and adults alike.

In a world where great customer service is rare, they went above and beyond. I’m incredibly grateful for their professionalism, warmth, and talent.

Highly recommend them to anyone in the area — we’ll absolutely...

They claim to have gluten free items on their menu but when we asked if they had anything the last was kinda of rude and said they were out. I have celiac disease so finding anywhere that had gluten free goodies makes me happy so when we asked when they would have more, also stating that I have Celiac's, she frowned and told us that eating there wouldn't be good because since it's a bakery it would still be mixed. So anyone with a gluten allergy or intolerance please avoid this place. I am sure it is good for those who are able to process gluten but for those of us who can't, maybe this bakery should indicate that they aren't copy...