La Herradura — Restaurant in Sheridan

Hot diggity! We rolled into Sheridan and I was expecting chain food and Pizza Hut food. What did I find? Damn near the best Mexican restaurant in the gosh darn country!

First of all, Sheridan is redoing its downtown. They've torn up the whole of Main Street. But you can still drive up here. We walked in we were a little worried... I had the carne asada, great big margarita, and a couple of grilled jalapenos on the side. Holy smokes, that was good. Wife had some sort of chicken fajita, that was out of this world. She had a frozen margarita, that was damn good. Our friends had anything from shrimp fajitas, enchiladas and burritos. And we started with a full-blown version of their nachos.

Their food was first class, a five-star taste extravaganza! This...

Wow. Based off of the reviews we were excited to eat here. Between the 4 meals we ordered, none were edible. The grilled cheese was greasy. Like, weirdly greasy. The chicken nuggets were mushy, pasty, and just disgusting. My wife's tostada was greasy, bland, and the shell was stale. The beef street taco was like if you took steak and ground it into little pieces and dried them out. But the real winner was rotten scallops in my seafood enchiladas. When a scallop reaks of fish, don't serve! It's bad! I had to scrub the smell off of my hands. The salsa was bad, and the spicy salsa wasn't spicy. This is hands down the worst Mexican food I...

This was our 2nd time eating there after swearing to never go back. There were not many redeeming qualities except the very friendly service. We were immediately greeted and seated by a friendly hostess to a high top table. The top was loose and wobbled badly. We asked to move and were happily able to do so. They got several things wrong when we ordered. Table mate ordered a pineapple jarrito and got a tamarind one. Ordered flour tortillas and received corn. Needed 3 to go boxes and got 2. The food was mediocre and not worth the hassle. Not the worst restaurant, but certainly not going back. Seems to...