Nikki's Greek Restaurant — Restaurant in Stillwater

OK, so... I haven't ever had most of what I tried when coming here that being said, I have nothing to compare any of this food to all I can give is my overall experience in trying something completely new... I was just finding myself completely tired of absolutely everything around and just wanted to step outside the box... Results were that I am so glad that I did!!!... I came by the drive thru to pick a few things up for us to try and see what we thought of them and all I can say is we will definitely be back!!! Want to try more... So, as I had no idea what to expect or where my taste would gravitate to I ordered the gyro, not the supreme.... The regular one... As well as the veggie sampler, a side of the saffron rice and baklava with an extra pita bread just to make sure we all got a try. It was a steep price as I notice they have gone up since the menu has been posted here. It was $23 for everything. However, there was a lot of food!! More than enough for 2-3 people and it was good food. Absolutely loved the gyro and the hummus and taboli ... The rice was a different taste as I have never had saffron before but I found it a good companion for the other food and the taste really grew on me quick. I completely fell in love with the little spinach pie pastry that tasted like the crispy dough that is used for the baklava with spinach and feta inside. It was hot, crispy, creamy and just ohh so good lol. I wasn't sure about the dolmas or the falafel at first .... The dolmas had a tart taste and the grape leaves were very different from anything I have had ever. The rice inside was well seasoned... The falafel was crisp on the outside and almost creamy inside.. Both things grew on me as I ate them. The dolmas were better later on at room temp dipped in the tzatziki ... they really grew on me taste wise then and I would try them again ... The falafel was better hot and fresh but was still good later on,I would definitely try it again as well. The tzatziki with everything was really good! The baklava was super sweet tasted of honey and nutty ... It was a definite winner for those that love honey. The gyro meat has a really good flavor and the pita was soft and warm. The whole thing was absolutely beautiful as far as food goes. Idk how else to describe it. The hummus and taboli were some of the best I have had. They were about the only things on the menu I was familiar with at all before yesterday. Really want to try a few other things here and will...

Staff, Food, and Service was all above board for me. Worth noting this review is during the COVID-19 Pandemic and they were operating under those restrictions.

Guy in the drive through I talked to, wish I remembered his name. Took my inquiry about if the Yogurt drink very seriously even though I was joking (asked if it was really Danimals). Which I revealed that I was after and he ended up laughing in what I perceived as a genuine manner. My wife wanted fried mushrooms as her side for her dish (forgot what it was) and it wasn't a normal side option, but they made it work

After the ordering experience, I pulled away and that same guy that took my order had ended up running my food out to me in my car.

Chicken Tikka Masala is what I ordered - it had good amount of chicken/curry ratio. Not too much rice. It came with 2 pieces of bread that wasn't on the menu either (about the size of your palm each). Overall, it was a good eat. I thought it was more food than I could handle but ended up eating it all since it was so good.

If I could change one thing it'd be my skepticism about the place rolling up. The sign could use some color to contrast against the Oklahoma grey sky - else it tends...

Would definitely recommend this hidden in plain sight gem.

Showed up as they were opening for a late brunch.

OMG the saffron ice-cream was mind-blowingly rich, the floral undertone was perfection. The baklava was rich and crispy. The white chocolate cake was decadent, the sponge was moist and you could taste the white chocolate.

The musaka plate was really good! The potato layer on top was fluffy, the veggie below was densely layered, the sauce was rich and deep.

The Pita Bread came out hot and soft with the veggie sampler. The sampler could easily been an entire meal in itself. The dolmas, lava cakes, hummus and tabouli were brilliant. Don't know what the little fried phillo pastry was called, but it tasted like feta, spinach and parsley, it was also very yummy.

The Pita dogs, were and still are a really good, inexpensive fast fill. Onion, mustard and pickle relish, with two dogs on a Pita.

Overall it was a really good meal. Quiet for before a football game, but we did open them up. Excellent service and...