Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Stillwater, OK — Restaurant in Stillwater

The newest restaurant in town is one I'll not be making a routine or quickly returning to. It's your typical sandwich and soup joint but will pizza. It's highly overpriced with the menu not even giving prices for their pick two option, leaving you with a surprise bill at the end. Portions were small and toppings very basic. Pizza prices were really high with a basic cheese going for $8 and then up with toppings. They also should do something about the amount of disposable plastic used inside as things like soup bowls can be paper instead of single use plastic that is getting thrown away. At least recycle it! College town options are cheap and with large portions, and none of which you bring...

Came in today with some co-workers for the first time. The food was good. My complaint is with the staff. One of the workers (appeared to be the one in charge) went out the back door to smoke. Due to the fact that she left the door open we could smell smoke in the restaurant which ruined the experience for us. (All 5 of us are non-smokers) When I asked one of the other girls behind the counter to close the door, she went outside and stood with the one who was smoking until she was finished (another 3-5 minutes) WITH THE DOOR OPEN! Not sure that I...

Everything is a la cart. When I'd gotten it on the last from deliver for work there was always a pickle included. I just thought a pickle came with every sandwich (reference to the name). They do sell half and whole pickles. I had to squint to find the bacon on my BLTA. It was 3:00 on a Sunday afternoon. The employees were disgruntled to have any customers, and they were still restocking. Hopefully from a large lunch rush. But, it is Sunday, in Stillwater, on college row, so maybe I had higher expectations...