Nonna Marie’s Pizza Restaurant — Restaurant in Totowa

This is actually the best food I have EVER eaten in my life! Everything I have eaten from Nonna Marie’s has been utterly exceptional and out of this world. My go to dishes weee the Chicken Parm Hero and Breaded Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo. The chicken parm hero had much more chicken than any other chicken parm hero I’ve had and tasted amazing - great bread, great chicken, great sauce, great everything. The chicken Alfredo was no doubt the best thing my mouth has tasted in my entire life. Huge sliced chicken cutlet with the absolute best Alfredo sauce ever. Best dish in my life. Also, I have gotten a chicken Parmesan with Alfredo sauce instead, and just wow. I couldn’t stop eating. It was like a dream for my taste buds. Plus the garlic knots had the most garlic and seasoning I have ever season - absolutely phenomenal. No matter what I ate or what I ordered from Nonna Marie’s, everything had the freshest, highest quality ingredients and were served in huge portions. The owner a was always extremely nice and personable whenever I walked in and made picking up food from here a very pleasant experience. I am actually so sad that Nonna Marie’s has been sold because I cannot eat the best food in the world ever again. This restaurant was out of its leagues and out of this world. An absolutely excellent meal and great service was guaranteed with every order and purchase. Although this beauty of a restaurant has been sold, I will never forget it, its food, and its...

Grew up in Wayne and lived in North Jersey most of my life, so I’m very familiar with many of the local favorites. I discovered Nonna Marie’s about 6 months ago, and I haven’t gone anywhere else since. Quite possibly the best traditional pie I’ve ever had. Crust is incredible. The pie overall is amazing. And I just had their Chicken Caesar Salad for the first time a few days ago and it is probably the best I ever had. The dressing is fantastic and homemade. The place is family-owned, and they are all exceptional people. Friendly, welcoming and warm. Can’t recommend this place highly enough, and I never write restaurant reviews, lol. You guys are...

The restaurant is a solid 4 stars. Pizza was good, counter help very nice. They even let me have pizza before I paid for it and told them I would pay it when I'm done being on the phone, which was really very nice.

The only thing I wish I was asked do I want the pizza a little more hot than when it was originally served, but it was fine the way it was served, I just like mine a little warmer.

Will I go back, absolutely. Very fair prices, good atmosphere, good food, trusting staff. I recommend them.

Scale of 1-10 on the quality, a solid 8, a good slice of pizza in a little gem of a place.

Nice job today. I'll...