Sweet Jenny's Chocolates & Ice Cream — Restaurant in Town of Amherst

I love this ice cream shop so much. I go about once a week usually with a few of my friends. I am 16 years old and I usually never have a problem there. But last night one of my friends and I road our bikes up there at about 9:40. When we got there we nicely walked in side and waited for our turn. When it was my turn I walked up to the girl at the counter and ordered what I get every single time I go to sweet jenny’s; a baby cone half black-raspberry half peanut butter in a sugar cone. Even though the baby cone is supposed to be 12&under, I get the baby because I could not finish a whole single due to the richness of the two flavors. I am will to pay the price for a single every time I get the baby because I understand that the baby is supposed to be for 12 and under. Well last night after I ordered the owner was checking someone else out right next to me and over heard what I ordered then proceeded to harasses me about how I “looked very big for a 12 year old” and “what was I going todo when I turned 13” I then told him that “I was will to pay for the single, I just can’t eat a whole one” which I think this is pretty fair because they are saving ice cream and making more money then the amount is worth. He then kept coming at me talking about how I it was odd that I was 12. I never said anything along the line of being 12 or under 12. I willing admitted that I was older than 12 but I didn’t see the harm in giving me a smaller size for the same amount of money as a single. I felt taken advantage of because of my age because I know if an adult ask for a baby he would have not reacted that way. I felt that he could have taken a different approach like asking me how old I was or tell me that they can do that but that I would have to pay for a single. I just was disappointed in the way I was treated because I felt that I did nothing wrong. The girl that was serving me ended up giving me a baby but charged me for a single which was fine. I just think that kinder actions could...

Sweet Jenny's is an absolute gem in Buffalo, NY! From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with an array of delights that cater to every sweet tooth imaginable. Their selection of ice cream and candy is unparalleled – from Star Wars chocolates to video game-inspired treats, there's something for everyone.

What truly sets Sweet Jenny's apart is the welcoming atmosphere fostered by the owner. It's evident that they pour their heart and soul into this establishment, always going above and beyond to ensure customers leave with a smile. Their dedication to customer service is commendable, and it's no surprise that our 5-year-old refuses to indulge in ice cream from anywhere else in town!

But the magic doesn't stop at the ice cream counter – venture upstairs, and you'll discover a treasure trove of unique gifts perfect for any comic or nostalgic toy enthusiast in your life. It's a haven for collectors and enthusiasts alike, adding an extra layer of charm to an already fantastic experience.

And let's not forget the location! Situated just a stroll away from the picturesque Glenn Falls park, Sweet Jenny's offers the perfect family outing. After indulging in delicious treats, take a leisurely walk around the block to marvel at the serene waterfalls and friendly ducks – it's a wholesome activity that encapsulates the essence of community and togetherness.

In summary, Sweet Jenny's is more than just an ice cream and candy shop – it's a haven for families seeking fun, nostalgia, and sweet delights. Whether you're a local or just passing through Buffalo, this establishment is a must-visit. Thank you, Sweet Jenny's, for consistently delivering five-star...

We ended up stumbling on this place entirely by chance, while wandering around and simply googling "best ice cream near me". Now, I'm typically not one to trust google (despite relying so heavily on it), but am sure glad I did on this occasion, because we ended up having some of the very best ice cream we've ever had, anywhere (including our hometown, Toronto, but also in other major North American metropolitan cities, as well as in the EU). The owners are some of the warmest folks we've met, and are mad geniuses with the flavours they concoct inside this beautiful 200+ year old marvel of a building. We ended up having about 5-6 different flavours, each one better than the last (or, more realistically, of an equally superlative calibre, merely just different). I love how they incorporate the ingredients so thoroughly, making the flavours taste like what they're supposed to taste like- not just in some lazy topical way which many other places do. The quality is objectively extremely high, and I cannot wait to visit again, so as to acquaint myself with other flavours. And as incredible as the their sweets and ice cream are, what really stole my whole heart was checking out the incredible comic book/action figure/arcade game collection upstairs, owned by the same evil genius who makes the incredible ice cream. Man, that was a walk down nostalgia lane... Talk of flavours, anyone seeking a big hit of nostalgia ought to make the trek to this Buffalo gem and hit up the upstairs after basking in the frozen sweet nectar downstairs. So glad to have...