Mozzafiato Pizzeria — Restaurant in Town of Brookhaven

Very wide selection and I am a big fan of vodka slices, so obviously ordered a vodka slice when I saw it. To my disappointment however, I was disgusted to find a beetle that had been cooked into the top of the slice. This got me thinking if there was a beetle on my slice how many other bugs could there be on the wide selection... I brought this up to an employee and rather than offering me a refund he offered to get me another slice, as if I would want to take the risk again after already being disgusted and having my appetite ruined... I can say with certainty that I WILL NOT be returning to Mozzafiato ever again.

After seeing the response from management I can also tell that they lack the ability the read and see that the beetle was "cooked" into the slice. It was not a bug that had just landed on the slice from sitting outside. Maybe the employees should take a better look at the food they are serving and management should keep the restaurant cleaner. Very unfortunate for a a fairly new restaurant...

I gladly drive 27 minutes (yes, I timed it) just to get my hands on Mozzafiato Pizza. In a world where bland, cardboard-like pizza somehow survives, Mozza is like a lighthouse guiding us lost souls back to real, glorious pizza. This isn’t just good pizza – it’s great pizza. Every bite is like a love letter to your taste buds, with flavors and craftsmanship that leave other places in the dust.

Now, my mother-in-law, bless her heart, insists on getting pizza from her local spot. And let me tell you, it’s… not great. They’re carbing up on mediocrity! I’ve begged her—pleaded with her—to drive the extra five minutes to Mozza, but no. She’d rather save time and eat sadness. What a shame. Literally what a shame.

While others settle for ‘meh,’ I’ll happily go the distance, because once you’ve had Mozza, there’s no turning back. Hands down, top 3 pizzas in my life. Oh, and don’t even get me started on the dinner dishes – just #amazing 🤌🏽

Do yourself a favor check...

Keep trying, hoping it was a fluke but tonight we ordered a Sicilian and my goodness what a mess. Looks like it was slapped together, thrown in oven with just enough cheese to call it a cheese pie with their sauce dripped over the top to hide that fact. Had half a slice and regretted even that!!! The sauce tastes tinny, very bland and too sweet. I’m sure it came out of a huge industrial can!! My sauce is cooked and tastes rich, theirs not so much. Very disappointed

Update: okay I will elaborate. There was barely any cheese on your Sicilian pie. I’ve had better sauce at home and out. I was pretty clear on the taste in original review. It tastes tinny and bland. Waste of our hard earned money. You overused the sauce to hide the fact that there was barely any cheese on your CHEESE Sicilian pie. It was burnt in some places, undercooked in others. Owner reaching out for to elaborate is just silly. I was perfectly clear and tried to be easy but now I...