Commack Bagels Deli Market — Restaurant in Town of Huntington

I work across the street and we order from them all of the time. They’re nice but they’ve consistently gotten my order wrong. When I’ve called the owner has argued with me saying I forgot to mention what I wanted and it wasn’t them so he will not be remaking my order for me. The other employees are very nice, and so was he when he came to return my money, but over the phone he challenged everything I said and told me I must not have asked for cheese when I know that I did. I also didn’t order soggy toast I asked for a toasted bagel and he refused to remake it for me after spending money there often. So good job you lost a whole business that ordered all of the time because you didn’t want to remake an omelette and bagel that costs you probably $2. I will be walking to the everything bagel next door from now on they are way better and never get the...

Not a huge selection of cold cuts... just your basics pretty much since it's a small deli. If you want any "specialty" cold cuts I recommend going elsewhere.

However, they're getting 4 stars since the sandwiches were solid - not skimpy in the least. Salads were also fresh. A good place for a quick sandwich or a bagel and they have breakfast sandwiches as well.

Will be back cause the sandwiches were on point.

Edit: back for a breakfast sandwich. Was delicious and fresh, but one slice of cheese on my BEC when the roll is around 5" round?? Come on... add a second slice to fill the circumference at least. Again, tasty and fresh, but no reason for 1 slice...

Folks, please stop going here. They started out as a great establishment but post pandemic they have gone downhill. They consistently get orders wrong. The portion size of meat on sandwiches as mentioned in other reviews is the truth. I once found a piece of string in a turkey sandwich. And whoever said this place has the best breakfast sandwiches is out of their minds. The bacon from this establishment is always limp and soggy. Never crispy. The Everything Bagel is right across the...