Molly’s Pizza — Restaurant in Town of Oneonta

When if comes to Pizza in Oneonta, you better bring your A-Game, and as I can tell you, after trying Molly's for the first time this past week, they certainly have! When we picked up the pizzas, the owner smiled at the boxes and said "Hope you guys are hungry, there is a lot of food here." and boy, he wasn't kidding. Lifting the boxes I felt them strain; these pies were LOADED. Spotlight on the Meat Lovers Pizza, which was HEAPED with meat. Bacon, rolled ham, I'm pretty sure there were clusters of ground sausage... I do not exaggerate when I say a single slice weighed in at close to 2 lbs! It was like eating an entire calzone on one slice. I tried to put it on a couple paper plates and they would not hold it! The next day I had a veggis slice which was piled high with broccoli, onions, whole cheery tomatoes, peppers and a killer sauce! It had nearly as much heft as the meat lovers! I have had every pizza in Oneonta and None have come close to the amount of topping we received on all the pizzas we ordered!

This pizza hasn't come to play, it came to win, and after my first helping I can say that when it comes to product value for your buck, when if comes to specialty pizzas, this may have just stepped into the top spot.

Note: Owner has taken a stance; no pineapple...

The presumed owner is extremely rude. Completely ignored me the first time I came in and was just flat out unfriendly when I asked him the prices. Then I tried going in a second time and he was helping someone with the doors closed from the mall entrance, completely ignoring me even though the guy told him I was there. So then I come around the front, walk in, ask him if I can get a slice which is already in the cabinet there, tells me he's super busy and can't help me and walks off. In disbelief by his attitude, I wait for him to come back to confront him about why he's being so rude. So he tells me he's behind on orders and isn't even open. Okay, so then why were you serving up slices to the person before me? The guy walking out said you were open in 3 minutes and you had slices in the cabinet ready to go. Sad that you're so miserable because the pizza is decent but the service alone is not worth it. Find another job if...

Only bad thing I can say about this place is that it’s not bigger for more ppl to sit & enjoy the ONLY GOOD (GREAT PIZZA!!) in the area!!! This is a hidden gold mine!!!! Been around here for years visiting and this is the ONLY PLACE THAT KNOWS HOW TO MAKE A GREAT TASTING PIZZA!! All the places that have popped up or been around for a while either can’t get the ingredients right or the way they cook it but this guy is on point! Finally a spot worth having a pizza coming from the city (Downstate). My family has lived up here since the 80’s and not one pizza place hit it out of the park except this one…. Would definitely eat here again. Fresh pie out of the oven, whew!! Again, can’t go wrong here. Hope this guy realizes what...