Cooley's Stone House Tavern — Restaurant in Town of Otsego

Not sure how an order for Roast Beef Sandwich Chili and Soda can be confused with an order for Bonless Wings and Soda. To top it all off, a patron chases myself and my friends out the door after hearing us talking about the money split because bill kept coming back wrong so instead of watching the bartender get more irate with us we just split the costs up between us. The lady thought we were being rude and called us a ton of names and even started swearing and shouting outside. When the Bartender and the Patron are both shouting at my group to not come back how can you give this place a good review? We didn't make the mistake of billing us wrong 3 times. you did. SO don't yell at us not to come back. 4/4/2019 around 12:30-1:00

P.S. Bartender shouldn't sit there talking about how dumb and stupid the owner of the place is and cheap they are behind his back in front...

My dad and I were looking for a place to eat after a long day and we decided to stop into cooleys. When we first walked in there was no AC and there was a weird smell throughout the whole bar. The bar looked really cool and the set up was great. However the bartender that we had was one of the worst servers we have ever seen. Before we even sat down she opened the beer bottle with her shirt and not with a bottle opener, coughed and sneezed into her hand without washing her hands and then proceeded to eat a bag of chips behind the bar where we could clearly see her licking her fingers after each bite. After not even a full minute in the bar we quickly decided we were leaving to go to another restaurant for the night. This bar feels like it could have been worth our time but with the experience we had within 5 seconds with the bartender we decided Copley’s was...

Do NOT get the nachos!

Came in with 4 friends, ordered a few beers, 3 burgers, a chicken sandwich, 20 wings, and a plate of loaded nachos. The burgers were great! Cooked perfectly and the brioche buns were delicious. The chicken sandwich was also delicious.

For the wings we tried the garlic sauce and the Cooley’s sauce. Both were spot on and the wings themselves were cooked perfectly.

The nacho platter says it comes topped with chili, jalapeños, black olives, and cheddar with salsa and sour cream on the side. I ordered it without the olives, and they were not included. However, the chili was basically a can or hormel chili with beans, and it wasn’t even hot. The cheese was burned, and there only 3-4 jalapeño slices. An embarrassment compared to the wonderful other dishes we got and they should probably remove this...