Phils Pizza 2 — Restaurant in Town of Oyster Bay

It is with a heavy heart that I pen this review for Phil's 2, a local pizza joint with a wide array of menu options. A recent experience has compelled me to share my encounter, albeit an unfortunate one, for the sake of transparency and awareness.

Having frequented Phil's 2 in the past and enjoying their diverse menu, I regrettably find myself recounting a nightmarish episode that unfolded after eating in there yesterday evening. It is with sincere reluctance that I assign a 1 star to this establishment, a rating driven by an unsettling bout of food poisoning.

Opting for a potato egg and onion parm hero with a rice ball on the side, I placed my order well in advance—1 hour and 15 minutes before their closing time. I did not assume old ingredients would be used. I have not had this hero in quite awhile even though it’s one of my favorites…and the anticipation of a s delicious meal quickly turned into a nightmarish ordeal, mere hours after consuming the hero. The subsequent chain of events was nothing short of distressing.

A couple of hours after eating in the meal, I found myself overwhelmed by symptoms that left me incapacitated. Profuse sweating accompanied by an uncontrollable flow of saliva(due to my body preparing to vomit), a painful stomach churn, and an acute sense of nausea ensued. The night was marked by relentless spells of vomiting and alternating between the restroom and a queasy stomach. The best part was vomiting into the near by trash can while on the toilet ! Definitely a fond memory I will always hold dear to my heart, thanks Phil’s 2 !

In a cruel twist of fate, I endured a sleepless night from 2 a.m. to 8:30 a.m., as the repercussions of the ill-fated meal held me hostage. The inability to even retain water served as a stark reminder of the ordeal I was subjected to.

Preceding this unfortunate occurrence, I had been in good health throughout the day, making the ordeal all the more perplexing. The distress I experienced, both physically and mentally, cannot be understated. While I acknowledge that one incident doesn't define an entire establishment, it's disheartening to attribute my suffering to a dining experience at a familiar locale.

Today, as I write this review, I find myself in a state of gradual recovery. However, my stomach remains unsettled, serving as a reminder of the havoc that unfolded due to what can only be described as a lapse in food quality.

While I hesitate to levy criticism, given my amicable interactions with the management and my physical proximity to the establishment due to my store being close by, I believe that transparency and accountability are paramount. My hope is that this feedback underscores the significance of serving fresh, safe, and wholesome meals.

In conclusion, the unfortunate experience I endured at Phil's 2 serves as a stark reminder of the fragility of one's well-being. As I navigate through the aftermath of this ordeal, I implore that a heightened attention to food safety measures becomes a priority for the benefit of all patrons.

P.S I will never return to Phil’s 2...

I have been to this place quite often when i am in the shopping center. Some of the items can be on the pricey side compared to other pizza places but the quality of their food makes it worth it. My visits are always worthwhile and i have never left unhappy. I would like to give a big thank you to an employee named Kristen who is always incredibly welcoming. Shes really sweet and i appreciate how she treats her customers. I called and asked her name so i could give her a shout out in this review because she deserves the recognition. Overall this place is absolutely fantasic and i couldnt reccomened them more! Give them a try today.

P.S -- IF an owner sees this, i would love to see you guys join up with the "too good to go" movement to help eliminate food waste! I always check if Phils 2 is on the app because a ton of pizza places are but unfortunately they arent. Hope to see you guys on...

Best pizza i've had in such a long time!! My boyfriend and I went about a month ago after seeing it on instagram, we're both huge foodies and had to give it a try. We got a few slices to share between us:

-the grilled cheese and tomato soup one, damn!! I was skeptical at first because I didn't think that would taste good as pizza but i was so wrong I ended up stealing my boyfriend's slice too

-the balsamic chicken one, so delicious the mozzarella was fresh so were the tomatoes would definitely recommend trying that one!!

-the mac and cheese one (boyfriend ate I didn't I hate mac and cheese it's a crime i know lol) he loved every single bite

We also got the eggplant pinwheel it was so flavorful and definitely something I would try again!!

I cannot wait...