Timothy Patrick's (TP's) Irish Restaurant and Sports Pub — Restaurant in Town of Penfield

This is a great dark Irish bar. Don't bring a book to read without a flashlight! Haha. I don't think of it as a bad thing, other than trying to read the menu! It makes you feel welcome and not on display to everyone. When your here you will know what I mean.

My wife and I came here for lunch. I got the Sligo Steak Sandwhich which is choice ribeye steak cooked how you request it (Always rare for me!) smothered in onions and mushrooms, and topped with American cheese. It comes with fries and I ordered it with a side of gravy. When has gravy not been welcome on a steak sub? It was awesome and exactly what I wanted today - the gravy was spot on.

My wife got the BLT burger with fried Avacado. It was cooked to her liking and she said that it was very good. We came here because she was in the mood for a burger. The burger patty was substantial. This was much bigger than your average 1/4 pound patty. It was easily 6oz if it wasn't a half pond.

We ate at the bar and I had a few beers. It was a great lunch that I'll repeat...

A nice Irish resturant and sports bar which has a georgeous fireplace to sit by and cozy up. Atmosphere was 5 star worthy with exposed brick nice wooden benches and tables. Quaint and comfortable. 5 stars for the food and cocktails. Appetizer: soft pretzels with spicy cheese dip. 6 large soft pretzels and the cheese dip had the right amount of heat. Soup: taco. Similar to a vegetable with tiny meat balls and a light spicy flavor. Shredded cheddar topped it off. Excellent. 5 stars. Entree: cottage pie. Similar to a Sheppard pie. Plenty of beef tips to accompany the pie. Large portion enough to take home for leftovers. My partner opted for the pot roast which included carrats and mashed potatoes. Tender and yummy. 5 stars! Resturant has a nice sized parking lot. Service was on the slow side and it wasn't a busy time when we visited. 4 stars for Timothy Patrick's and we hope to visit again when...

I ordered a pot roast that "came with" a salad. I instead received lettuce hearts that were inedible, cold, hard meat atop fake mashed potatoes and grey-looking verges. I didn't finish the salad and couldn't take a second bite of the entree. There is no doubt that the meal was at some point frozen and reheated.

When I first mentioned the food was tough and still cold, the waitresses said I was wrong (that the meat was supposed to be tough) then later apologized after trying to cut through it. She still charged me for the lettuce that was supposed to be apart of the entree and was also left uneaten.

In addition, my boyfriends food was just as disappointing. It was undercooked, cold and definitely not fresh.

We ultimately returned all food and ended up being charged $30 for 2 beers and 2 lettuce bowls. It was a truly...