Jerry and The Mermaid — Restaurant in Town of Riverhead

Nestled in the heart of Riverhead, Jerry and the Mermaid is not just a restaurant; it’s a beacon of culinary excellence that stands out in the local food scene. This gem of a spot has won my heart and taste buds with its absolutely best-in-town burgers and duck wings.

From the moment you step in, you’re greeted by an atmosphere that’s as inviting as it is charming. The staff, with their unwavering friendliness, makes you feel more like a guest at a friend’s dinner party rather than a customer. It’s this warmth, coupled with the delightful aromas wafting from the kitchen, that sets the stage for an unforgettable dining experience.

Now, let’s talk about the food – the main event! The burgers here are nothing short of a masterpiece. Imagine a perfectly cooked patty, its juices sealing in an explosion of flavors, nestled between a soft, yet firm bun. It’s a harmonious blend of texture and taste that leaves you craving for more with every bite.

But it’s not just the burgers that deserve a standing ovation; their duck wings are a revelation. Cooked to a crispy perfection, they strike a perfect balance between the richness of the duck and the zesty seasoning. It’s a daring and successful twist on the classic wing that has me coming back for more.

Behind this amazing food and service is the owner, whose passion and friendliness permeate every aspect of Jerry and the Mermaid. It’s rare to find a place where the owner is as much a part of the experience as the food, but here it’s a reality.

In conclusion, Jerry and the Mermaid is more than just a restaurant – it’s a culinary journey that leaves a lasting impression. For anyone in Riverhead looking for the best burgers and duck wings, along with a warm, welcoming atmosphere, this is the place to be. Hats off to the team for creating an experience that goes beyond just dining – it’s a celebration of good food and...

First time visiting Jerry and the mermaid, drawn by its location right next to the aquarium. Figured it was worth a shot during my aquarium visit.

Food 4/5 Went with the blackened fish sandwich and was pleased with the execution. The fish was prepared well - not greasy despite the blackening technique, which can often go wrong. Clearly fresh ingredients throughout. The cole slaw that came with it was fresh and flavorful, a nice complement to the sandwich. Solid preparation overall that hit the mark for what I was hoping for. No digestion issues.

Service 5/5 Staff was genuinely friendly and attentive throughout the meal. Everything moved quickly - from ordering to food delivery to check handling. Really can't ask for much more in terms of efficiency and friendliness.

Ambiance 4/5 Comfy, relaxed atmosphere that's perfectly casual. The kind of place where you can settle in and enjoy your meal without any pretense. Our table was a tad uneven, but it didn't really affect the dining experience.

Cleanliness 4/5 The place was in good shape overall. Bathroom was clean and well-maintained. All the visible areas were clean, though it didn't pass an inconspicuous area swipe test. Nothing that would concern me about food safety or overall standards.

Parking 3/5 The aquarium location is both a blessing and a curse. Having two lots available helps, including an overflow area, but the aquarium traffic definitely makes parking more cumbersome than it should be.

Value 4/5 Moderate pricing that felt fair for what I received. The food was tasty and the portions were reasonable. Good value for the location and quality.

Overall 4/5 Excellent lunch spot that delivered on what I was looking for. The easy walk from the aquarium makes it a natural stop, but the food and service quality make it worth seeking out on its own. I'll definitely be back to see what else...

My first visit to Jerry and the Mermaid was nothing short of magical. Nestled along the seaside, this charming restaurant boasts not only impeccable food but also a breathtaking setting that instantly transports you to a coastal paradise.

From the moment we stepped inside, we were welcomed with warmth and hospitality that made us feel like longtime regulars, despite it being our first time there. Jerry himself checked in on us multiple times, ensuring that every aspect of our dining experience was nothing short of perfection.

Despite the bustling Friday crowd during Easter weekend, Jerry’s accommodating nature and honesty about the wait time made our decision to stay worth it. And oh, was it worth it! As we strolled along the docks, soaking in the ocean breeze, anticipation built for what turned out to be a phenomenal experience.

The food, oh the food! Each dish was a masterpiece, bursting with flavor and made with the utmost care. From the freshest seafood to delectable appetizers, every bite was a delight to the senses.

But it wasn’t just the food that left a lasting impression. The atmosphere of the restaurant, with its cozy yet vibrant ambiance, added an extra layer of charm to the entire experience. Surrounded by the sound of waves and the sight of boats swaying gently in the harbor, we found ourselves lost in the moment, savoring each bite and each precious moment spent at Jerry and the Mermaid.

In a world where exceptional dining experiences are rare gems, Jerry and the Mermaid shines brightly as a beacon of excellence. Whether you’re a local or a visitor passing through, do yourself a favor and make a reservation at this seaside paradise. You...