Pied Piper — Restaurant in Town of Webb

After a wonky weather day at the local Waterpark, we were exhausted and in search of comfort food. We found it just up and across the street at the Pied Piper! After thoroughly scanning the menu, and finding it very hard to choose from the many delicious sounding options, I approached the window where a very pleasant young woman greeted me. I said "Hi, I have a question, I noticed all of your fried snack options and wondered if you have a sampler platter?" She smiled and quickly said "We do not, but I will make you one. What were you thinking?" and began to list the exact items and exact number I would have chosen. It's like she was in my brain. We were snack soul sisters! When our order was ready she'd even added fries to it! My son ordered the pulled pork sandwich platter and ate it so fast that I'm not sure he even chewed, or took a breath! The food was amazing! I don't know how we had room, but we went back up to the front of the building and both got small soft serve cones before our long drive back home. We will definitely be back the next time we visit Old Forge! Please make the Sampler Platter a permanent fixture! It's...

Pied Piper is a great place to take your family for a quick lunch in Old Forge. 3.25/5

I've come here many times since I was a kid. The past few years my family and I take a camping trip once to twice every summer and we frequently stop here at least once. Pied Piper has that nostalgic vibe with their overall appearance, nothing really modern is here. My father-in-law and I both ordered fish sandwiches earlier today, however our fish was extremely overcooked and dry. They were quite busy so I didn't want to try and request new ones.

The cheese fries were pretty solid, and were crunchy enough to not get all soggy from the cheese. Also my pepsi soda was fresh and great.

Lastly the ice cream is in my opinion the best reason to come here. There is a great selection across the board with a lot to offer!

I'm giving my rating based on my current experience, I think had I gotten a burger it would've been less disappointing. Nonetheless, I will still come back here and update my review if the experience is better! I still recommend...

Reply to owner - How would she know there was metal hidden in her sandwich without attempting to consume it? I notified you immediately of the metal in her food and you did not offer a refund or remake. She then spoke to you about it again after our meal, and you refused to refund the sandwich.

The metal cord twist tie that my daughter found in her mouth while she was eating a pied piper sandwich could have been very dangerous. The owner (who admitted that he himself had made the sandwich and added the metal wire) was on the premises and could have given her a refund for this sandwich, but refused to. This whole scene suggests sloppy and indifferent management which could affect your safety. I suggest...