East Coast Eats — Restaurant in Warrenton

So i got the Italian Sandwich. My friends and family ordered apps and other foods. Apps took 42 minutes to get to us, the food was immediately served after. Sandwich was advertised as 12 inch, it was 8. Was supposed to have several types of meat in it, it had almost a half inches thick stack of ham, and one layer of whats i assume was pepperoni. There was a single slice of american cheese, which wasnt bad. Then there was a large, and i do mean large, pile of shredded iceburg lettuce. Which had been heated with the sandwich, robbing the lettuce of its only redeemable factor, the crunch. The peppercinni slices were perfect, not too thick, not too thin. Another frustrating factor was the fact that the whole sandwich was heated with the lettuce on its, so when it sweat, the sandwich became soggy. The italian dressing however was amazing. Don't get me whron, i wish there was any other flavor to the sandwich then italian dressing but it was a soggy hoagie style hot dog bun with a brick of ham and italian dressing. This was all that came with my 20$ + meal. I am very dissatisfied with it.

Alternatively My friend got the Philly sandwich, it looked, smelled, and apparently tasted amazing. It was just over a foot long and you could tell was carefully made. Calzone was massive, and well seasoned, although the red sauce was heavy on the tomatoe paste, and light on seasonings resulting in a super thick, sweet sauce.

The staff here was amazing, and very friendly, but as i can only fully comment on the food that i got, i gotta say that this was probably the worst italian sandwich ive eaten since subway.

Update: So been a while since i last stopped her, and i went back. This trip i had the calzone, and fries. The depth of flavor this go round was amazing, with the ingredients, the cooking, the sauces. The sauces that i got this go round were a meal unto themselves, i cannot express the difference in my last trip versus this one. Please, if you get a chance, stop by and get something,...

Came on a Sunday with a group of 4. We were seated right away. It was about 1/3rd full. Seemed fully staffed. They didn’t take our order or bring drinks until after 20 minutes. Didn’t even take our drink order until after 10 minutes. We then waited 1 hour and 15 minutes for our food. One of our hamburgers took an hour and a half. We stood up and were going to leave but they assured us our food was coming soon. We waited 20 minutes more. They refilled our sodas and water once after we stopped a server to ask them to. Never once did they refill our sodas and water again the entire time we were there even though servers passed our table with empty glasses many times. We had to go into the kitchen to refill them ourselves twice after waiting with empty cups for a long time each time. We were seated near the kitchen and it sounded like chaos. Staff were being chewed out loud enough for us to hear.

The food was not great. DO NOT order any of their fries options unless you like them salted to the point they are inedible, and believe me, we tried. The Italian hoggie was soggy. The burger was overcooked, besides being asked for medium. The pizza was completely white and soft on the underside, but maybe that is East Coast style? The Philly Cheese steak was okay.

We were there for an hour and 50 minutes and were very frustrated by the end. Server gave us 20% off our order but that didn’t make it worth it at all. I don’t expect this place to be in business for long, given how few people were there at noon on a Sunday.

We were going to go next door to grab some of their cupcakes from Killer Cupcakes, which the owner also operates, to bring back to friends but didn’t want to risk it given our experience at the restaurant. Besides, we didn’t have much time after spending...

Finally! Another new real restaurant and not some fast food joint, has arrived in Warrenton! I’m not sure I understand some of these 1 star reviews. I think some people just want to see new ventures fail. Don’t hesitate to try this place out! From the moment we stepped inside the newly clean, renovated space, the experience was great. From being greeted with a warm, sweet smile, to the attentive service, to the tasty/huge portions of food, until the moment we walked out, and were bid a nice farewell, we enjoyed our experience. The menu is good; not too big, but just big enough to make you ponder on your selection. I got the Pittsburg Stacker with shaved beef, which was HUGE. You have a choice of meats to choose from, stacked between two slices of yummy bread with coleslaw, cheese, and fries. I ended up taking half home, and ate it for lunch the next day. It was very filling! My husband got a burger and enjoyed it immensely. Real, homemade burger pattie. Not some packaged Costco prefab burger. The fries were crispy and tasty. The pirogies were definitely drenched in a lot of butter, but they were tasty and tender. I'm used to a more browned pierogi, but a small side of these were fine. I'm not sure I'd order the larger portion. The sautéed onions that accompanied the pirogies tasted good on my sandwich, so they didn't go to waste! What impressed us most was the owner came out to thank us and check if we enjoyed our food. That's definitely an authentically east coast thing to do. We will be back. I'm looking forward to trying a pizza and...