Millburn Deli — Restaurant in Westfield

Their system is terrible. I ordered several sandwiches online. Said it would be ready in 20 minutes, went 30 minutes later because the previous time my order wasn't ready and had to wait for another 20 minutes. I order 5-6 sandwiches at a time so i can understand my orders taking longer to make.

This experience, the girl in front was refilling the drink coolers. Went behind the counter and asked me for my name and said the order wasn't ready and said it will be ready soon. She went back to filling up the coolers. This was an hour before they close. Wasn't busy, I waited another 40 minutes. The lady making the sandwiches asked me what order I was waiting for since she was done with all the orders. I told her my name and found my order was sitting on the shelf all this time. I saw a guy put the bag there awhile ago. Failure in the system because the runner doesn't announce the names as he puts orders on the shelves and the front counter person is oblivious because she is filling out the drink coolers.

I like the sandwiches but not worth the aggravation of ordering online but yet waiting for a long time for my order when it isn't busy. This is over a month ago. Parking isn't easy in downtown which is why I...

Avoid this place like the plague!! There are a million sandwich shops out there and this ain’t it. I placed an order online today for 1sandwich - email said it would be ready in 30 min which is a long time to wait but it’s lunch and I was hungry so be it. I get there at the expected time I was told and was told will be ready shortly . Ok fine . 10 min go by…..20 minutes…… I ask again bc surely one frikkin sandwich can not take this long to make !? ‘Will be ready shortly’. So again I wait 10 More minutes…… by now I feel like a fool standing there staring at the counter and advise everyone walking in to order to just leave bc it’s not worth it. Ended up being an hour and 15 min after I put my sandwich in and still no sandwich !?! I asked again and was told ‘it will be ready shortly’. Unfortunately I don’t have all day to wait around for 1 sandwich so I left starving and with no food. This place is HORRIBLE - everyone in the front was complaining and unhappy. To the business owner ...

Hello everyone – I visited Millburn Deli for the first time today and tried the Reuben sandwich.

I ended up paying $22 total, including an extra $6 for added pastrami. Honestly, for that price, I expected something more substantial. The portion was just not worth it, and that stuck in my head the whole time – it really took away from the experience.

Sure, it was tasty, but I know other places nearby that charge me less and give me a Reuben just as good — but 2 to 3 times the size. That comparison made this sandwich feel even more underwhelming.

For educational purposes, I even went back to double-check if this was the correct order. And yes — it was. I mean, come on… even without the extra pastrami, the sandwich looked sad. Just two thin layers? Puh.

The taste was decent, but definitely not worth the price, and certainly not enough to bring me back.

Sorry, but no sorry — I left feeling disappointed and ripped off.

PS: there was ONE piece (slide) of...