Darkwater Games — Attraction in Mashpee

This place is the absolute WORST. Not only did they falsely advertised selling at 70 percent when we called and asked about selling some pokemon cards. We drove 30 minutes to there establishment, and got an offer of about 30 PERCENT. AND no negotiating on their already outrageously priced cards. For instance, a card that is saying 38$ on both TCG and price charting, they wanted to charge 55. And when we brought it to their attention and said what the value of it was, they gave absolutely not one single shit. Do NOT waste your time or energy. Zero stars. Do NOT recommend.

To respond to your ignorant response, first of all when my son called on the phone and asked what rate you buy cards at, he was told 70 PERCENT. not 60 and 20 percent whatever. You obviously have no idea what your employees say about your own bussiness then. We sat there looking them up on proce charting and TCG And knew exactly what the prices were. You dont get to just make up a price of what YOU think its worth. Absolutely ignorant employees, who don't even attempt to negotiate or work out a deal. I wish you would've had the same energy when we were in store. But of course only a reply after the fact....

I think that judging from other reviews Darkwater seems to be a really awesome game store in general, however I went to Darkwater for the first time with the specific purpose of selling some magic the gathering cards and I think the amount offered was on the lower end. I went to the closest competitor and their offer was 66% higher. Having said that it seems to be due to store policy that they offer really low buying prices for magic cards (you can check the owners response for the specific policy, from what I understand using "tcg low" means they base their buy price on the lowest possible price the card is being sold for on tcgplayer regardless of other factors like card damage, something which the store I ended up selling at doesn't use). Other than that my experience was great, the staff were awesome and seemed like cool people. It seems like a great place for any other usual LGS function, but specifically if you are looking to sell cards I'd recommend trying other game stores...

Stopped by this shop for the first time to get some MtG cards and was blown away. First off, they have a great selection of table top games, Pokémon, lorcana, Magic, and more.

Their MtG booster and collector pack selection is magnificent. I can’t remember the last time I saw a Homelands unopened booster pack.

The prize of this store is their massive and extremely well organized singles / bulk selection. I recommend coming here if you have a specific list of cards you’re looking for. You must use their computers to find them, add them to a cart, and submit it so they can find all the cards for you. All the singles / bulk are in the back. I put in an “order” right there and within about 5 minutes the young man working there had all 10 of my cards ready for me. If you’re looking for a place to casually browse through bulk, this isn’t going to be the store for you.

They also have display cases of really valuable MtG and Pokémon cards that was great to...