Bethany Sports Cards Plus — Local services in Bethany Beach

🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 Bethany Sports Cards Plus – A True Hobby Haven with Even Better People

I don’t shop online with Bethany Sports Cards Plus—I make it a point to go there in person, and honestly, it’s one of the highlights of my collecting journey. From the moment you walk through the door, you’re greeted not just by a great selection of cards, but by two of the kindest, most genuine people you’ll ever meet. The owners are the heartbeat of this place—welcoming, knowledgeable, and simply a joy to talk to.

They remember your name. They ask how you’ve been. They truly care. It’s the kind of warmth and sincerity you rarely find in today’s world—let alone in a retail environment. Their passion for the hobby is infectious, and their integrity is unmatched. There’s no pressure, no hard sell—just good conversation, honest dealing, and a shared love of the game.

The shop itself is a collector’s dream: clean, well-stocked, and thoughtfully curated. Whether you’re hunting for a vintage gem or just stopping in to chat and browse, it’s the kind of place you want to linger in.

Bethany Sports Cards Plus isn’t just a store—it’s an experience. It brings back everything I love about collecting: the stories, the nostalgia, the personal touch. I always leave with a smile (and usually a great card or two).

If you’re anywhere nearby, do yourself a favor and go visit. It’s more than worth the trip.

HIGHLY RECOMMENDED—this is what the hobby...

Just checked out the card store on Oct. 23 at 2:30 PM. I had my 3-year old son on my shoulders. We walked through the door and as we stepped inside, I lifted my son off my shoulders and into the ceiling fan directly above us. Other than being scared and a little sore, my son was fine...We went outside, wiped some tears away and then came back inside. THAT PART is no one's fault.

Another customer remarked that my son is a tough one and smiles. The card owner doesn't ask how he is, say, phew, that's a close one--nothing. Instead he launches into a lecture about the kids who run into his store and then states explicitly that his store isn't really for kids.

Well maybe that's a problem, store owner. You set up shop in an area kids love to hang out, THE BEACH, then exclude those kids from participating in a hobby that they propped up, rather than making them feel welcome.

Maybe that lack of extra business is why he also charges $95 for a box of Bowman that I found a minute later online for $50.

I suggest you take your money elsewhere. Sure, he's got a business to run, but if he's purely about his business, then you should be too, and you can find better deals from sports card stores online, and still support small business owners without the...

Bethany Sports Cards Plus is better than ever! The new owners have truly transformed this shop into a must-visit destination for sports card and Pokémon card collectors. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with warmth and genuine enthusiasm. Their exceptional customer service makes every visit a pleasure—they really take the time to understand what you’re looking for and offer helpful advice.

The pricing is fair and transparent, which is a refreshing change in the card world. You can trust you’re getting a good deal. The inventory is fantastic, with a great mix of vintage and modern cards, plus they’re constantly adding new items to keep things fresh.

What stands out most is how much the new owners care about the community. They’ve created a welcoming environment for collectors of all ages, and you can tell they’re passionate about what they do. Bethany Sports Cards Plus is now my go-to shop, and I highly recommend it to anyone in the area. You won’t find a better combination of great products, fair pricing, and friendly service! Thank you guys so much, and big shout out to Max who was so kind to give us such a great experience! Best of luck to you guys and we’ll be seeing you...