Anna Maria Island Frozen Yogurt & Acai — Local services in Holmes Beach

My girls and I had a terrific experience at this new business on AMI. We love build your own ice cream and frozen yogurt. I’m Gen X. So think TCBY. You get a bowl and fill with your favorite flavor or flavors of yogurt. Add toppings of your choice. And enjoy. The had gluten free and dairy free options for those with dietary restrictions. And lots of candy, fruits, syrups and every other topping you can think of. Staff was chopping fresh pineapple while we were there. Truly something for everyone with every taste. Fun games to enjoy while eating and relaxing. We also got some unusual high quality stickers.

I had chocolate with m&m’s cuz I’m boring. Daughter 1 had cookies and cream yogurt with gummi sharks, Andes mints, marshmallows, gummi worms and cherries. Daughter 2 had birthday cake yogurt with dark chocolate chips.

Only load onto your bowl what you intend to finish. You pay by weight. If you go hog wild and let your kid fill their bowl sky high with ice cream and candy that they just throw away, you pay for that. So don’t let your eyes be bigger than your stomach and for the selection and quality on the island, the price is fair and same as other shops on island. We did spend $20 for 3 dishes. But I spent $33 the night before at one of the other shops down the street for 4 cones. So just don’t be a glutton.

In same strip was a cute boho beach wear shop that does fun hair braids and you can get your nails done a couple doors down. Nice furniture design shop to browse and buy next door, too. We walked but they had parking. Across street is library and skate park. So make a...

We stopped by Anna Maria Island Frozen Yogurt just 15 minutes after their grand opening today, March 6, 2025, and wow—what an incredible experience! This place is an absolute gem. The yogurt was hands-down delicious, some of the best we’ve ever had, and you can tell they’ve poured their heart into every single detail. From the meticulously presented setup to the thoughtfully curated selection, it’s clear this isn’t just another yogurt shop—it’s poised to become an iconic staple for the Anna Maria Island community.

We even got to chat with the staff about how they chose their yogurt, and I was blown away by their process. They didn’t cut corners or go for the cheapest option; they went all in on quality, testing extensively to find something truly special that leaves a lasting impression. My wife and I are already counting down the days until we can visit again. If you’re on the island, this spot is a must-try—trust me, you won’t be...

Amazing service here! From the moment we entered the store, the staff were very friendly and welcoming. They offered to let us sample their fresh açaí and yogurt flavors. Their toppings bar has many good options and lots of fresh fruit choices. It was a very refreshing treat for a day out in the sun! It’s also a very nice place to hang out in.

I also want to thank the owner, for helping me return a lost item I had left behind while my family and I were there on vacation. She was very understanding and went out of her way to make sure it would get delivered to me back home. We will be returning back on...