Sweet P's Pantry — Local services in Oconomowoc

My first time, I received 35 dollars of chocolates from my family secret Santa. So disappointed, but don't want to let my family member feel bad, so I'm letting you know I only gave you a 3. knowgave you a 3, I could have given more stars, but I'm very disgusted with the 8 pack box of TURTLES, the chocolate so hard it snapped in half and hurt my teeth, and then there's the HARD carmel that was either cooked too long, tasted burnt when it was finally broken. But could not chew it. CARMELS AND CHOCOLATE SHOULD BE SOFT NOT LIKE PECAN BRITTLE. BUT I LOVED the milk chocolate toffees. And the milk chocolate carmels were ok, but the chocolate fell right off the hard carmel. Either the candy cooks needs lessons or you sold very old candy at...

Wonderful little shop filled with an incredible amount of handmade sweets. I stopped in for an anniversary gift and was greeted with lots of warmth and helpful suggestions.

I got a variety of chocolate and caramels. The cocktail truffles were spectacular, and the pumpkin spice caramels were exactly as advertised. I've gone back for a few other goodies which were also great. It looks like their selection changes with the season so I look forward to seeing what comes next.

Prices are a bit higher than expected, but are justified by the quality. And when you're buying for special people and...

I wanted something to enhance the dessert table at my daughter's bridal shower. Wow! Am I glad I called Sweet P's! Orson showed as much enthusiasm and excitement about the shower as I felt! He was super responsive through email and calls. He shared multiple possibilities on what might work for the shower after asking me great questions about what we were looking for. Oh my gosh, the truffles, toffee, and dipped pretzels were amazing and received huge praise at the event! We were so impressed with the customer service and quality of the treats that we will order another selection at...