The Junior League of Long Island Thrift Shop — Local services in Town of North Hempstead

This used to be my go-to thrift shop. The designer does some phenomenally inspiring displays, and the store is clean and well-organized. It is still all of those things, BUT....I stopped going there regularly many months ago when the prices absolutely skyrocketed. They are charging astronomical prices, and their merchandise does not warrant what they are charging. Twenty dollars for a used, pilly sweater? Broken christmas ornaments, $5 each? Chipped vase, $20? Previously worn, non-designer shoes, $35? Hardly 'thrift.' They also appear to be much more selective in what they accept in an attempt to appear more 'boutique,' but this has simply eliminated the fun assortment that thrifters enjoy browsing through.

The atmosphere in the store has changed and is no longer the fun, lively experience it used to be. Such a disappointment. I went there a few days ago to confirm that things had not improved, and sadly, they haven't. When I commented to one of the employees about my concerns, she acknowledged and mentioned several changes in managers. I prefer to shop where I know my money is going toward a good cause--which it is here--but when it's no longer fun to shop, what's the point?

Also, notice in browsing the reviews here that the shop only responds to the 5-star reviews; would love to hear their response to...

This shop needs to bring back the staff member who was in charge of their window/shop display that was employed before pandemic. I understand they just reopened recently due to pandemic and a flood at location, but this is the 2nd time I've come here and am disappointed with their ugly displays!! Most importantly, the merchandise is nothing to talk about. I used to love coming here almost every week and find great things, many pieces with tags and designer pieces also. Now they are selling junk that have worn looking clothes. Previous staff would not put out junk! And why on earth would they place dowdy menswear up at the front of the store. So...

This place used to be a great place to donate clothes and other articles. It has since become a nightmare. I have tried to donate beautiful suits and nice clothes recently and have been blocked at every turn. First tried to drop off and told I need to make an appointment. then tried to make an appointment know one picks up the phone. Then I get someone on the phone and they tell me I have to wait three weeks before I can get an appointment. Really! There are so many people out there that have nothing and this is the response from a thrift store. I will be finding other places...