Holsten Jewelers Since 1912 — Local services in Village of Scarsdale

I had been on the hunt for a jewelry store that I could consider as my go-to place for jewelry repairs and purchases. Fortunately, my quest led me to Holsten Jewelers, a charming, family-owned gem nestled in the heart of Scarsdale. From the moment I stepped through their doors, I knew I had found something special!

The first thing that struck me about Holsten Jewelers was the warm and friendly environment... it instantly reminded me of my favourite jewelry store back home. Gary, the store owner, and his staff warmly greeted me when I walked. And, I noticed this was consistently done with every client who walked through the door. You can see they are intentional about welcoming and making every client feel valued. It's not always something you experience in retail these days, so it truly sets Holsten Jewelers apart.

Beyond the staff and the warm environment, I also love that Holsten offers a wide range of pieces at different price points, catering to a diverse clientele. I've gotten awesome gold studs and silver hoops there... and look forward to hopefully getting more awesome pieces in the future :).

After discovering Holsten Jewelers, I can confidently say I've found "my jeweler". The exceptional service, warm atmosphere, and extensive selection of jewelry make it the ideal place for all my jewelry needs. Whether you're a first-time visitor or a regular... whether you're seeking to repair a cherished piece, find the perfect gift, or simply explore their treasures, Holsten Jewelers should be your first stop. Thank you, Holsten Jewelers, for making Scarsdale a little brighter with...

We had purchased smaller gifts from Gary in the past so we knew that when it came to buy an engagement ring, we would enjoy working with Holsten’s Jewelers again.

Gary gave us his attention and focus while also giving us space to discuss amongst ourselves. He worked with us to find a stone that met our budget and was incredibly beautiful. Gary offered to either have an initial meeting to go over the engagement ring basics or to let us lead the charge by sharing the types of stones we liked in our search thus far. At our first appointment the team had several stones with different characteristics so that we could understand the nuances between lab diamonds and then leverage that to narrow down our search. Overall, we had three appointments with Gary and his team, each time everyone was incredibly patient, respectful, and helpful. Gary was the grounding force throughout our process. Engagement ring shopping is stressful enough, but Gary really made us feel calm and made the process significantly more enjoyable. I sincerely recommend working with Gary & Holsten Jewelers - we had a fantastic experience and look forward to...

About 2 months ago I began the process of searching for an engagement ring for my girlfriend. After going to a couple of different places I was impressed with some of which that I saw, but I wasn’t completely sold. I was then recommended by my future father-in-law to visit Gary at Holsten Jewelers to see what he had to offer. To say that I was blown away would be an understatement. Upon my first time meeting Gary he was extremely caring and asked all the right questions regarding what I was looking for and the timing it all needed to be done. The second time we met he presented me with several options, taking the time to explain the difference between each one. I finally found what I wanted and Gary made it come to life. My now fiancé is over the moon happy with her ring and I have Gary and everyone else at Holsten to thank for that. Holsten Jewelers has a customer for life in me and I couldn’t possibly recommend them...