Martha's Vineyard — Restaurant in Bay Lake

Pros Wings were tasty Decent draft beer selection Fennel was a nice touch in the mussels Attentive staff Cons Small portions for the cost (5 wings per order, ~dozen mussels, not enough bread) Outdated, typical hotel lounge feel Horrible acoustics, two loud groups essentially made it impossible to have a conversation While attentive, staff wasn’t over friendly or welcoming. Overall Not a magical experience. Much prefer other resort lounges like Territory Lounge in Wilderness Lodge or the Ale and Compass Lounge at the Yacht Club. Won’t return except to maybe grab a...

Ordered there Halloween cocktail which was lovely. Brought Hubby back a few hours later to have one. Had to sent then back twice they didn't even look like the photo or what I had earlier. The taste was all wrong. 3rd time mine was good but hubbies was just OK and we had been there 40 minutes and had dinner reservation so had to accept it. Don't have photos on the table if what you are going to serve looks nothing like. You are letting your...

To be clear, this is a review of the vanilla shake only. It was without a doubt the worst shake I have ever had. I don’t know how a milkshake can be not sweet, but it wasn’t. The consistency was just bizarre. It was like trying to drink whipped cream through a straw. Save your $15 and go...