Papa Johns Pizza — Restaurant in Carthage

Disappointed to say the very least. They’ve only been open in my area for a few weeks and I can already tell you they won’t get much service. Just placed my first order, took over an hour to receive our order which is fair considering the weather conditions. However, want not expecting to receive pizza that was COLD and tasted as if it had been sitting for over 30 minutes before being delivered. Upon delivery they forgot 1 of my pizzas and my order of wings. To which they had to come back and deliver them, and they tasted as if they left them went back for them and then brought them back. 100% they should have made my food that their driver forgot FRESH. Will gladly take my $40 to dominos where our pizza is always fresh and food...

Every time I come here, they remember me and greet me so warmly. They’re fast and always get my order correct first try. They offer extra things like paper plates and napkins. Plus it’s great pizza. Just all around a great experience! I typically like to wait to give a place a review to make sure I don’t have one great experience and terrible experiences afterwards. I can attest that I’ve received nothing but positive experiences from this Papa John’s specifically, and we’ve been going here for...

I'm so glad Papa John's came to town... I got tired of eating Pizza Hut all the time. This place definitely has way better food and service than Domino's in town. I ordered from here a few times food is always been hot and fresh no complaints. I would definitely...