Pizza Shark Chatham — Restaurant in Chatham

I tried them out for the first time today, I got the great white and a plain cheese as well. The presentation was great, looked just like the pictures, flavor was also good. It was however very hard to bite through, throughout both pizzas. Very spongy! It was a true workout. My jaw was literally burning/sore after two pieces. I arrived just on time so the pizza wouldn't be sitting long as they have very little parking and suggest you don't come early. I immediately opened the boxes when I receive them to air out for the short ride home. That tells me the sponginess wasn't due to being in the Box too long or anything like that. I would try them again in the future hoping it was just how it was made this time and not their...

I was looking for a restaraunt on the day right after Labor day but many businesses were closed. I am so glad I stopped by Pizza Shark after visiting two closed businesses. As I ordered the Aloha pizza, the owner(?) striked a friendly conversation with us and kindly explained why many stores are closed today. When we told him about our honeymoon and that we were going to get a take out to eat it while watching the sunset at the Chatham lighthouse, we were given extra service that we didn't expect and greatly well taken care of. He also explained the local area and helpfully guided us. We really appreciated the kind gesture and loved the pizza. We wish you happy life and...

Pizza Shark is the real deal for anyone who loves NYC pizza. The crust is thin, crisp, and perfectly foldable with just the right chew, and the sauce adds a touch of Cape Cod sweetness while keeping that bold New York balance. Fresh, high-quality toppings (the ricotta + chili oil combo is amazing) make every bite stand out.

Service is fast and friendly—pizzas come out hot and quick, which makes it perfect whether you’re grabbing a slice on the go or sitting down with friends and family. Great flavor, great speed, and great vibes—easily the best slice...