Went here and it was super gross. Here is what we experienced: The food was abnormally greasy. I've never had pizza crust so greasy in my LIFE! Not to mention, the pizza we got had cheese that was burnt and black! Talk about a shock. The place was nasty! Caked up dirt on the window seals, food and crumbs under drink machines, tables left uncleaned for nearly 30 mins with NO rush there or customers to wait on, the bathrooms were GROSS and had NO baby changing table in the restrooms (I know VA Law does not require this but 99% of restaurants who want families to eat there have them!). Our plates had hardened food spots on them. We scraped it off but this was gross too.
If this place can actually take pride in the appearance of its location, and clean It we would likely come back. Theres no reason for Gossip in the back on downtime when you have nasty tables, floors, bathrooms, etc. If you have time to lean, you have time to clean.
We likely wont be back, as I couldnt imagine the condition of the stuff in the kitchen. Please do better! The pizza has so much potential. I am hoping that this...
Read moreOrdered, and paid for, self-serve fountain drinks but everything was flat and the kids running the place didn't really seem to care when I let them know, and offered no alternative. One came out and put ice in the machine but that's all. I finally went back to counter and asked if they had anything to drink and she pointed at a tea dispenser behind the counter and said "help yourself." Pizza ingredients were fine, but pizza was only warm, maybe a little above room temp. I wonder if they have pre-baked crusts and just warm them up with ingredients. This one was a puzzle. When we got ready to leave, I had to sneak behind the counter to get a box to put the pizza in to take with us because no one was in site. No one checked on us, asked how things were, how the pizza was, nothing. Sorry, don't like writing bad reviews, but thought people need to read this, especially the owner who left three kids in charge who were, apparently, really in over...
Read moreWe decided to dine at Casey’s because nothing else in Floyd was open on Christmas Eve. We were hungry and didn’t bring high expectations to the meal, but the thin crust alfredo pizza was a lovely surprise. The crust had a delightful snap without being cracker thin, and the layer of alfredo beneath the golden blanket of mozzarella was on par with sauces we’ve tasted from such establishments as Forlini’s in NYC. While folks may neglect Casey’s for places with more notoriety in downtown Floyd, you heard it here first: Don’t sleep on Casey’s or Casey’s will sleep on you. And you’d be a fool not to jump on their...
Read more