Baisley's Deli — Restaurant in City of Peekskill

I used to be a long time customer when Kenny was the owner. Since August of 2019 he had sold the place. THINGS GOT A LOT WORSE STARTING WITH THE NEW OWNERS. THE OWNER STOLE MY REVIEW FROM THE PAST AND LISTED ME AS FRANCISCA G. IN WHICH IS NOT MY NAME AT ALL. I’M A GUY.

I TAKE MY 5 STAR REVIEW BACK AFTER MANY COMPLAINS ABOUT THIS PLACE BY MANY PEOPLE INCLUDING MYSELFx

I BOUGHT A HAN AND CHEESE SANDWICH ON A ROLL AND A BIG OF LAYS CHIPS COST ME $10.75. ONLY 3 1/2 SLIVE OF HAM ON THE SANDWICH.

INCLUDING THE AFRICAN LADY TRIED TO RIP ME OFF. DIDN’T PUT ME CHEESE ON MY SANDWICH.

PLEASE DON’T DISRESPECT THE NAME BAISLEY’S DELI LIKE THAT THE FIRST IN WHICH HIS LAST NAME WAS BAISLEY WAS THE BEST. THEN MY GOOD FRIEND KENNY TOOK IT OVER AND DID GOOD WELL. UNTIL HE SOLD THE PLACE TO THESE PEOPLE THE PLACE GOES DOWN HILL.

I SPENT SO MUCH MONEY HERE AND I GET DISRESPECTED LIKE THIS. WE DON’T ACCEPT PLAGIARISM. TAKING MY REVIEW WITHOUT MY CONSENT AND PUTTING WITH A DIFFERENT NAME ON YOUR WEBSITE.

WANT A GOOD DELI TRY VALLEY BROOK MARKET BY THE HEALTHCARE CENTER ON MAIN SHREET.

WE WON’T BE RETURNING HERE. UNLESS...

I am giving this deli 5 stars across the board. I went in there today for lunch and I ordered the Philly cheesesteak. And let me tell you, this sandwich far exceeded my expectations. I am from Philadelphia originally, so my standards on the matter are high. But I have to say, when it comes to their cheesesteak, they are doing EVERYTHING right. From the quality of the meat and how they slice it, to the bread, to the cheese ratio, it truly tasted like home for me. It 100% would be accepted in any bar or restaurant in Philly, and that is saying something. I am convinced that the person in the kitchen is either from philly, or has family in philly haha. Either that or they are just a big foodie because they've clearly done their research.

Thank you very much for the delicious lunch today. I will undoubtedly be...

I don’t usually do reviews on places, but this place became a disaster after the new owner moved in.

Starting off with my wedge that I ordered as I was speaking to the lady what specifically I want she responded with ‘I heard you already’. As a turkey, ham and cheese with a bag for Lay’s chips and a bottle of water cost $17.25.

When I opened my wedge I was surprised to see that there were only 4 slices of ham and turkey and left out my honey mustard that I requested for. Unlike other dels I been to through New York City Manhattan they loaded the wedges until you can’t bite in to it for about the same price.

Very disappointed here with the new ownership as the old owner Kenny used to loaded up the wedges for his customers.

Used to be a go to but not anyone it is not the same Balisley’s Deli...