GoodieBox Bakeshop — Restaurant in Cliffside Park

I heard about GoodieBox Bake Shop through my children's school. I decided to try them for a custom cake for my daughters 2nd birthday party. As a full time working mother of a 2 year old and 3 year old, it is hard for me to make phones calls. Email is more efficient for me. Carrie, the woman I worked with, emailed wth me until we decided on the type of cake, size of cake, design of cake, filling and type of icing. They were extremely easy to work with right from the beginning. When my husband brought the cake home, I was completely overwhelmed with what I saw. It was better than what I had expected. It looked absolutely perfect! Everyone was very eager to taste it. With one bite everyone started to rave about how good the cake was. I can honestly say it was the best cake I have tasted and I worked as a catering coordinator for 11 years. 2 days later my mother came for a visit and she had some and said the same thing! I am having a second family party for my daughter and we will be getting the exact cake. No changes need to be made. I am excited to work with them in the future. Payment is also done electronically which makes working with them a lot easier as well! From beginning to end, the experience and product exceeded all my...

Don't miss this jewel box of a bakeshop for celebrations both big and small! We ordered a lemon raspberry cake for a family celebration and it was such a big hit. Tall, elegant, and sprinkled with freeze-dried raspberries to hint at the flavor inside. It looked like the top tier of a wedding cake! Everyone was so impressed with it visually but once we tasted it, we all loved how moist and lemony it was. The guests were all raving about how balanced the buttercream was. The texture and sweetness was just right. The guest of honor even swiped some extra frosting off someone else's plate, which I've NEVER seen him do!

In this day and age, everyone wants a cake that photographs beautifully. But sometimes a gorgeous cake will be too dry/dense or the frosting just tastes like colored butter. You never want a second piece. It really can be a lottery sometimes. But with this gorgeous, delectable cake we definitely hit the jackpot!

Thank you, Carrie, for putting as much thought into the flavor as you did on the presentation. It really made our celebration...

I wouldn't hesitate to order from here again :) For my baby shower, I did some research and found this establishment online. Out of all the places I called, Carrie (the owner) was the only one who offered for me to come in. Everyone else just asked me to select a flavor, send them a pic, etc. which is ok, but I like to see where I'm potentially buying from and possibly have a sample taste since after all, it's cake we're talking about.

When my mother and I met with Carrie, she very kindly answered all our questions about flavors, options, and pricing (which was reasonable). She also gave us a sampler. Honestly, I'm not a cake person and I found everything I tried delicious!

I had brought in a picture of a "Piggies in Mud" cake to ask if she could replicate it and it wasn't a problem. The cake looked amazing and was a total smash at the shower. We wound up ordering her chocolate cake flavor, which is delicious! She delivered it herself to our door at 10am the morning of. We really couldn't have been happier with the experience,...