Johnny Pies NY Pizzeria — Restaurant in Coconut Creek

*uPDATE August 27th, 2025

Look at the pics below. This pizzeria is on Fire! Dennis the owner is hands on and always making sure everything is made perfect and CHRIS made my Ultimate Sausage Roll..if you like Sausage And Peppers this roll will make you feel like you died and gone to heaven .it is AMAZING..Shout out to Chris For making this the Ultimate Sausage Pepper & Onion Roll! And that is a big statement from someone from Brooklyn, NY! This is a special roll..extra sized and extra special. This is NOT something they normally make..if you want one check in and ask for Chris .and tell him Joe Sent you and you want his special Sausage Pepper & Onion Roll..tell him you want the "Brooklyn Joe Fuhgertaboutit Special Sausage Roll .it is special order and of course costs more..but worth Every Single Penny .if your a gavone like me from Brooklyn you can eat it all one sitting..if not you will be getting two meals out of it..and of course there is tons of other goodies to order...the Sicilian is awesome..white slices always hit the spot. Could never recommend this place enough..head over now either yourself or with friends and family and let your Taste buds ENJOY this Amazing Delicious Pizza & Italian Food. Buona Appetit!

OMG! FUHGETABOUTIT! Today was my first time trying this place. Someone had mentioned to me in passing as I am from Brooklyn NY and always saying can't find a good NY Pizzeria here on South FL..well as I am still trying to catch my breath and recover from almost passing out I can tell you this is now my number one place! I couldn't believe my eyes when I walked in and saw not ONLY Rice Balls but my favorite besides Pizza in NY..A CHICKEN ROLL!!! I knew of only one other place that knew what a Chicken Roll was and made them and they closed. But at any rate as soon as I saw that and asked if it was indeed a Chicken Roll I ordered it and waited in anticipation for it to come out of the oven..and WOW!! My prayers have been answered..I now found a real NY Pizzeria and that is also evident in the Cheese they use..GRANDE cheese is the best cheese and only cheese a Pizzeria should be using. So they use the best ingredients too. I will now be frequenting this Pizzeria as it will be my number one place to go and anxious to try many other items that I am sure will be amazing! Good Job Johnny Pies! Highly Highly Recommended, especially if your from NY or NJ as you will really appreciate this place and feel like your back home...

This place is amazing!

I was nearby and looking for a good restaurant. Family member was craving pizza!

This was the closest.. And I will be honest… my family member said that is a hole in the wall restaurant!

We looked for others and nothing was close by. I said, “some of the best pizza places are small shops like this!”

So, I went in.

I ordered the Johnny’s works, a soda, 12 wings, a slice of cheese pizza, sautéed broccoli, and spaghetti with Alfredo sauce for the little one.

Everything was perfect!

Even the soda was ice cold.

I had not one complaint (which is rare since many years ago my husband was a chef and I was in fine dining!)

And then comes the customer service!

Wow!

Great, great attitudes from ALL staff!!

In fact, (in South Florida), none like I have seen.

No, it is not a FANCY restaurant or fine dining.

But, it is a cute, CLEAN, small pizzeria!

I am so impressed that we can’t wait to go back!

In addition to everything that they provided, this was during the three days of rain and flooding that we had!

I asked for help (because I felt I had no choice)!

And said! “Could you hold my two year old while I run all of this food and her bag to the car! I will come right back and grab her!”

It was raining so heavily that day!

The young lady was so accommodating!

She took Bella, went to the table to clear the two plates, and I ran to the car!

I came back….

The little one was with her behind the counter… in her arms, and while she took an order over the phone… and she had a garlic knot in her hands…(which kept her busy the whole ride home!)

And I was highly impressed!

I only wished I had my camera on me, as I would have loved to have saved that photo! (But it was in the car!)

Thank you so much for the great food and great service!!!

First time here! Won’t...

I lived in NYC for 30 years before moving to South Florida in 2020. The quality of pizza down here has been disappointing to the point where I gave up. I happened upon this place because I work at the jail down the street. The pie is my favorite down here by far! Great flavors in the sauce and a great crust. But I have had the same issue TWICE now. I hate very hot pizza. To me hot pizza is like hot lasagna and the flavors need time to meld together without the steam. Also, my mouth is sensitive to the heat. I let this be known clearly by saying "not too hot". The first time I accepted partial blame bc the guy at the oven said "I'm waiting for a fresh pie." To me I know that means "sauce and mozzeralla soup" but I accepted it. I wound up boxing it and giving it away to a teenager outside becuase I only hava a limited time for lunch and can't wait 30 minutes for pizza to reach ideal temperature. So yesterday I asked for 2 pepperoni. Not only did they make the wrong pizza, but when the guy- who I had never seen before- took the proper slices, I reiterated "just warm, not hot". 5 minutes went by and I was served what looked like cheese and pepperoni sauce on top of crust. I immediately asked the girl to box it, complained that it was too hot. It was placed in a box, no "sorry about that" or anything. I offered it to a customer sitting there. I eventually put it on the table outside in case maybe a homeless or poor person wanted it. This won't happen a third time. And btw it wasn't busy- only 2 other customers were in there. So 4-5 starts for great pizza, but that doesn't matter if it isn't served the way I like it, especially as a regular who has been telling...