Your Pie Pizza — Restaurant in Columbus

This is my first time at Your Pie and a first at trying peach on a pizza. Now pineapple was a pleasantries surprise after a lifetime of speaking out against it on a pizza. But peach, peach was really pleasant. It doesn't have as much acidity as a pineapple would, but the taste was not too strong, and smooth, velvety even. It's hard to describe. The short of it is that this pizzas is perfectly balanced (as all things should be) and I have to give this one a strong recommendation. I'll be back to try the Kickin' BBQ Peach pizza next. This Peach Prosciutto pizza was light and fluffy, easily bendable but crispy on the outside enough to eat folded without toppings spilling out.

In short, really good pizza, y'all gotta try this joint. The folks in there were super friendly and welcoming, the store was clean and neat. I came after work and there weren't a lot of people in, so if you have a large group, chances are you'll be able to find plenty of seating whether...

Food is amazing, and that’s why I am giving it a five star.

But PLEASE to the owner DEEP CLEAN this place. At the beginning you guys seem to care about this but with the years it’s gone down hill. The coke machine is disgusting growing stuff around the ice dispenser. The bottom of it is rusting and leaking. The ice tea counter needs some deep cleaning. The gelato cooler is no nasty around the edges. The shield where you make the pizza is not clean. The menus have change which is great but a Caesar salad without croutons really?

Y’all can do better than this, I know it’s a lot of young folks and they always being so sweet, but management and owner the cleaning is y’all’s responsibility and the maintenance of stuff. Not young ones! They are there grinding and make y’all money. Do...

This was my first time trying the Whitesville Rd Your Pie, since we usually walk to the Uptown location. The menu is similar, but I did notice a few differences with pricing. This spot also offers some unique options like a beef brisket sandwich and a keto-friendly crust, which I haven’t seen at the Uptown location.

One thing to note—this location doesn’t serve alcohol (I think they lost their license), but that didn’t take away from the experience. The staff were very friendly and helpful, and they really loaded up my build-your-own pizza with plenty of toppings. The pizza came out delicious, and we finished it off with some gelato, which was also really good.

Overall, a great visit with friendly service, tasty food, and some unique menu items. I’ll definitely...