Pizza Mill — Restaurant in Custer

I'm going by votes from my fellow Yelpers on pizza tonight, don't let me down!

Ok, thank you fellow Yelpers!

We ordered our pizzas for take out, even though this is one of only a few restaurants open on Sunday evening, we wanted to relax at the hotel. After ordering we walked to Dakotamart for a few items then returned to Pizza Mill. We had to fix our bike rake before getting our pizza and as we were the young woman (late teens!?) from inside bright out the pizza and wings!

Then we asked for napkins, plates and forks which she obliged by getting for us.

Parking is limited and tables inside even more so, only 5 tables! They do have some seating outside but like I said we took it to the hotel.

Now for the food! We ordered a 12 inch with various meats. What can I say but delicious! The crust was good but could have been fantastic if it had cheese in it (after all it's think enough). We also ordered 8 wings. They simply come fried, to golden perfection I might add, and you get sauces to go with it. I got the bbg which had a delicious, smokey flavor.

Overall they had a very friendly staff person, sorry I didn't get her name, and delicious food. Be sure to stop here if you're in the mood for some yummy...

The waitress gave us the pizza that was for the table in front of us, so they had to wait for a new one! We had already gotten part of our order, so we she called out the type of pizza she had, and we said it was ours! We had ordered a medium, and this was a large! She came out and said we had the other parties pizza and acted like it was our fault! Then she said we would have to pay for the bigger one! Oh, and then she came out and told me that our pizza wasn't even ordered, so we had to pay for our LARGE pizza that was their mistake! Meanwhile, she brought out the other parties' pizzas, and when they asked for extra marinara, she told them they had to pay extra for it! We ended up leaving half of our pizza since we had no place to store it, which is why we ordered the size we did!! A total waste of time and money we would not...

The pizza was fantastic! Crust was very thin on the bottom and rolled up thick on the edge. I'd recommend a fork and knife over picking up the pieces as it's so thin. The outer crust was very light and flaky, very tasty. The sauce, cheese and toppings were delicious. We tried a supreme and a one topping and they were both very good. Thinking about other pizzas that are my all time favorites, this place might crack the top 5. I will be back next time I'm in the area and we'll see if they can replicate the experience before I cement it in my top 5 but I'll definitely be thinking about it until then.

We came on a Saturday afternoon in mid October, they were steady but not busy. Our service was fast, the restaurant and...