Goodfella's Pizzeria Sanford — Restaurant in Florida

To say I was ELATED to hear that Goodfellas was once again embarking on another journey and would soon be opening the doors is an understatement!! We have been lucky enough to have had many AMAZING meals for the last 2 decades. Not only filling our bellies, but most importantly, fueling our souls with many beautiful memories made with friends and family! If you also love to support your local family owned small business and want a place to gather for DELICIOUS food, fun and family..... THIS IS THE PLACE TO GO!!!! You really can't go wrong with anything on the menu but a few of our favorites and what we ordered just this last trip are....

Appetizer MUST HAVES Baked Meatballs Mozzarella and Tomato GARLIC KNOTS (at least a dozen, we order 2 dozen) 😋

Salads... Antipasto salad OMG there's Caesar is to die for my husband loves the house salad as well but what you really need is the house dressing LOTS of it LOL

Pizza.... Any pizza really but one of our favorites is the shrimp and bacon And had a pepperoni

Entree's..... Shrimp Sinatra Penne alla vodka Chicken francese

Desserts Cannolis of course But you have to make sure to order the Toasted almond cream cake

And can't forget the array of choices when it comes to delicious 🍷🍷🍷

P. S. To the one-star review leaver. You're probably not aware that you can click on your profile and see all of your reviews. Seems to me you're a competitor in the area who should probably be spending more time worrying about your establishment instead of taking time out of your day to leave negative reviews that aren't even true on somebody else's. Seems you have left -1 star reviews on all the pizza places in the area as a matter of fact every review you have ever left which were seven of...

My family and I dined in and had a great experience! I used to work with Sal ( owner) years ago. So I already knew the food was going to be delicious! However, the food definitely exceeded my expectations!!! I had breaded chicken Sinatra ( it usually comes with shrimp but I changed the protein) and all I can say is I could have drank the sauce that’s how good it was!!! My oldest daughter got pasta with vodka sauce and she loved it. She actually forgot it at the hotel we were staying at and she was SO disappointed. My husband and son got baked pasta dishes which they LOVED! Our baby was a little cranky because we had drove from SC and it was a long drive for her. Well Sal heard her getting upset and gave her a plain garlic knot before the food got there and that definitely helped her calm down! Speaking of garlic knots , we got those for an appetizer. And again the sauce they gave us for them was definitely drink worthy. Lol. I recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for delicious authentic Italian food!! From the pasta dishes, to the pizzas/calzones/stombolis, to the appetizers and desserts you will NOT be disappointed!! ( I’m half Italian so I know good Italian food!! 🇮🇹) I just wish they had a restaurant near Charleston SC where I...

WOW. Just WOW. Goodfella’s Pizzeria in Sanford completely blew us away!! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with warmth, kindness, and the kind of hospitality you dream about. Our server wasn’t just good—he was OUTSTANDING. Genuinely one of the best we’ve ever encountered. His energy, attentiveness, and kindness are the reason we’ll be coming back all the way from Philly—just to experience it again.

Now let’s talk food: 🔥 Mozzarella sticks – perfectly crispy on the outside, melty on the inside. 🔥 The wings – flavorful, juicy, and addictive. 🔥 Calzone – cheesy perfection in every bite. 🔥 Pasta for the little one – simple, buttery, comforting. 🔥 Even the lemonade and sweet tea were spot-on. And don’t even get me started on the cannoli—pure bliss.

✨Every single item we ordered was a hit, and the prices? Unbeatable. You feel like you’re getting way more than what you pay for—delicious food, incredible service, and that rare feeling of being truly taken care of.

We’re RAVING. We’re OBSESSED. We’re making this spot a regular stop every time we’re in town.

Goodfella’s, you deserve ALL the stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ and then some. Thank you for such an unforgettable experience....