The Fuel Counter at the Market — Restaurant in Huntington

UPDATE: Updating my review to four stars for several reasons. First, the quantity of toppings they give you for the price is really generous. Second, the wraps and salads really do make this place a good option for a quick bite. I found a few menu items that are good, but it’s best to just custom build your own because the price is the same. Service is also really good/friendly.

OLD REVIEW: This place has room for improvement which is better than being bad. I ordered the Italian sandwich. The bread was very low quality, and pretty tasteless/bland which somewhat ruined the sandwich. The toppings were extremely fresh and good. But I would rank them pretty far behind some other sandwich options in the immediate area. Someone else in my party ordered a steak pizza, and similar problem. Decent quality toppings, but cucumbers and steak? They need to rework the flavors they consider in their different items. It looked to me like wraps and salads are the items to order here. I don’t think the one-size-fits-all approach (salad, sandwich, pizza) works all that well. I’ll probably give them another shot and update my review as they figure out the kinks. Like most places not everything on the menu...

Husband called to place a pickup order at 7:20 PM after fighting with the online system that would not let us select toppings for the pre-made pizza options. My husband asks "hey, can I place a pickup order?" to initiate the conversation. Worker rudely goes "you know we close in 30 minutes, right?". I overhear them on speaker as my husband tries to explain that we live within 10 minutes of the store and I tell him to just hang up. We were trying to pay within business hours and be mindful of closing times to begin with. Used to really love eating the food from here because there are so few fresh options in town, but this really set an awful tone, and I personally will think twice before ever trying to eat...

UPDATE (12/27/2021): The incident in the previous review must have been a one-off thing. They have since stood by their "One Price, Endless Options" claim. Since their food is excellent as well as their quality of service, The Fuel Counter redeemed itself and has earned back all 5 stars.

As of February 24, 2019 regrettably I must downgrade from 5 stars to 2 stars. Their claim "One Price, Endless Options" is deceptive. They nickel and dime on the "endless options". It didn't use to be this way. They should list all the prices for everything extra and be...