Square Grouper Key West — Restaurant in Key West

Last Friday evening, four of us had dinner at the Square Grouper in Key West. Our server was very pleasant; unfortunately that is all that was good about it.

One of us found a long hair in her salad. They asked if she wanted another, sorry about that. 'It happens'.

I had asked for the appetizer of fried scallops as a dinner, and was told that could be done. The scallops tasted odd, unlike any I have ever had, and were actually distasteful. The server noticed that I was not eating but did not question whether I didn't like it, if it was okay, or if I would prefer something else. And for this accommodation. I was charged $50.00 for five scallops. Wow! I ate one and disposed of the rest.

One of us had fried grouper, their alleged specialty, and it wasn't cooked thoroughly.

It is understandable that they would aim for quick turnovers, however the hovering and repeatedly asking if we were finished when we clearly were not was too much.

I have not one positive comment regarding the Square Grouper, and if you are considering patronizing this restaurant I would suggest...

Best meal of the week and wow are we thrilled to have eaten here. Heard great things from other locations so tried it on a day trip to KW. Early arrival after opening and was seated quickly but the spot was already getting full. Cozy tables in the back with a view of the kitchen was cool. Didn't smell like fish which is always a great sign when doing seafood! The food was all outstanding. Deep rich flavors, generous portions of protein and the grouper was the star of the meal. Had it picatta style and the key lime sauce and caper combo was absolutely amazing! Calamari was lightly battered and flash dipped so you could enjoy the actual flavors and we loved the pork. I honestly can go on and on but this was a repeat for us. Service was attentive without being overbearing and the staff were all warm and friendly which is lovely when coming with kids. Also loved that the kids menu was diverse but easy for kids who want normalcy...

I love this restaurant and have been a regular patron for years. I was thrileld to see one in Key West and it is absolutely beautiful with outdoor seating as well. The food is consistently awesome, presented well and tastes delicious! This was my first visit to the Key West location and Lizzie and Stephanie greeted me and were super pleasant. They escorted me to a beautiful seat with chairs and booth. Daniel was the server and even though it was his first day he was very efficient. I ordered an Old Fashioned (rum) and it was just as I enjoy them, black cherries and an orange slice. Very very good. I ordered the panko crusted mahi that comes with jasmine rice and a salad. Absolute perfection! They now offer half portions and I should have ordered a half so I'd have room for the wonderful bread pudding of the day. They are always over the top delicious too. Great job Square Grouper team!!! Thank...