Sweet Tooth Cottage — Restaurant in Liberty Township

I just had THE best peanut butter cookie EVER!! I’ve ordered from this bakery before (the custom decorations are amazing); however, it had been a while since my last visit. When I saw the adorable Halloween cookies on Facebook, I figured I had stayed away long enough and I decided to make the 1-hr round trip. I am sooo glad I did!! I knew the Halloween-themed cookies were gonna be great, but I had never tried the peanut butter cookies. Did I say that they are THE best I ever had? My only regret is that I didn’t buy more. I guess another road trip is in my immediate future lol. The bakery is clean, product placement is inviting and the customer service was outstanding. Trust me when I tell you that you’ll have a hard time (and a fun...

Phenomenal! Everything is fresh, delicious, and such a range of treats! The owner is also incredibly generous-I won both cookies and a gift certificate last year at our elementary school's art auction. We went in today and got THE BEST chocolate chip cookies (and I'm picky!), plus a fresh, soft, delicious oatmeal chocolate chip cookie and an equally delicious snickerdoodle. In addition, a PHENOMENAL vanilla with vanilla frosting and chocolate with chocolate frosting cupcakes, chocolate frosted brownie AND amazing buckeyes. We will be...

First time in purchased 4 cookies the girl was going to put them in a box I asked if I-could just have them in the individual single order basic sleeves and she goes I will need to charge you .50 more a cookie...... wow that's insane she then took the cookies and did some Kind of clear packaging with the name of the cookie on it totally unnecessary and I do not understand why the single paper could not be a choice. Was a big turn off for a first time customer. I totally would have been fine if she said .50 extra...