Formaggio's Pizzeria — Restaurant in Madison

Pizza was fine, nothing to really complain about but there are some local spots i like better..

Issue is the first (and last) time I've come here i ordered a lunch special, advertised 5 bucks. Got that and an order of fries, I pay, total checks out no issue. Ends up he "misheard" and instead of correcting the issue just looks down and ignores the situation. So no fries, paid extra and there was no inclination to fix it. Just give me my fries or my money back for it, not a big deal but really? Awful service, expected better

EDITED REVIEW: It's been some time, and I actually frequent the place a lot more now. Pizza is solid, but the slices are the biggest in the entire town. Two slices and a soda for 5.99 is really good. Service is significantly faster and more accurate. I...

They said it was Brooklyn Pizza. I grew up in Brooklyn and crave a slice from yesteryear. I walked in. The cheese looked just right! Lots of oil. That's a good thing. Use a napkin. Pie had just come out of the oven. Always the best time to have a slice. Cheese oozed! You know you're going to burn the roof of your mouth but you keep going anyway because it is that good. One trick when it is that hot is that you can't fold the slice because your mouth will burn for days. Let the heat dissipate and you continue eating. Crust is also good, thin but not too thin. Sauce works but it's the cheese that I was missing most. I...

I was so pleased to find out that this pizzeria is under new management/owner. The atmosphere has become much more welcoming. The new owner provided exceptional customer service, and all the employees were kind. Most importantly, the food was DELICIOUS. The Drunken Grandma pie was scrumptious, and the mushroom pie was also great. I have been back twice since the first time I tried it three weeks ago. All in all, a great place to eat at for a casual dinner with family or for a nice night in eating pizza and...