Mammoth Pizza Co & Slice Bar — Restaurant in Mammoth Lakes

I come from New York NOT NYC where are gas station pizza is better than most Pizzerias. I know pizza! I eat it for breakfast, lunch, and dinner back home. I walked past this place and said $&@? That smells like REAL pizza. So the next day my 2 friends and I skied from Daves (the top) all the way down to here. I got a large cheese pie that’s what we call it back home it was ready in about 10 minutes maybe less I said no way can this be as good as it smells if it only took 10 minutes. Well it was amazing. I thought I was back home especially since PBR was only $3.00! I went to a wedding once and Utica Club was $5.00 that’s outrageous! But anyways great place really nice workers 10 out of 10. Probably the best on the west. Wait till I tell my local gas station guy about this pizza. He’ll probably be drunk on Utica Club but that’s the way us upstate people live. We live free. Super good Pizza and you get a huge pie for $30.00 HUGE!!!!! You’ll have a good time enjoy some $3.00 PBR. Maybe next time there will be $2.00 Genesee...

This was the first and last $40 pizza I will ever buy. Definitely not worth it The young lady working the counter did not greet me or any other patrons that walked in to order. She just stood there and looked around the pizzeria. There was no, "Hi, what can I get for you." We took the pizza to go. We had the Bubba's 20". The crust was blah. I'm not sure what they mean by a 48 hour dough resting period because this generally allows the dough to cold ferment and develop flavor. It also builds up a bunch of gas in the dough. When you hand toss, which these pies are not, you never touch the edge of the dough because you will degas it. This pizza was like a flatbread. The crust did not rise. I've been making pizza in a wood burning over for years. I guess I am a...

I never expect much from a pizza joint located in the middle of a touristy area, and I was not wrong in setting my expectations low. I always say there’s no such thing as “bad pizza” but there will always be a distinct difference between average pizza and great pizza. This is average pizza. Conveniently located but underwhelming. The dough is floppy and your fingers will be white from the flour on the bottom. The cheese is really the only part that keeps it at a 5/10 and not lower! But the service is good and again, it’s just the place to go if you’re a tourist looking for a pie. This was my first stop in finding the best pizza in Mammoth. My...