The Godfather of Morristown — Restaurant in Morristown

First I will begin by saying this is my first time going there based on a recommendation from a friend. It has a nice looking facility, and the food was prepared when I was arrived.

The bread was fresh to their credit, which can make a break a sandwich. The chicken was also fresh, but was the equivalence of about 2 dinky chicken tenders topped with messy cheese and what I believe was cheap cannds sauce.

When I arrived there was nobody at the register but there was a kid in pajamas hanging out behind the counter. I didn't know if I was walking into a slumber party or not. When the girl came to the register from the back, she was very friendly and asked if I was paying cash or card. I said is it the same price for both? she said YES, so I paid with card when I could have paid with cash. Turns out when I later checked my receipt, that was not the case. I do not like to get nickel and dimed or support businesses that like to charge fees for every little thing . I have plenty of options. So now I just bought a $14 sandwich that was ok, but certainly not great, and I get to my destination only to find out that I paid extra for a credit card and they didn't even include napkins. How do you charge 14 for a average to below average sandwich like that and not include napkins? I'll give them credit for using fresh bread, but I would not recommend this place.

Update* This is laughable, notice the childish response on any criticism or feedback in all their reviews. Common denominator . My review was complimenting the food quality but the portions and professionalism needed help. Immediately he drops the victim card and tries shaming a potential return customer about something I said nothing about. Maybe spend more time addressing ways to get better instead of having to be right...

Went in after being on the Green (right down the street). They had inside seating spread out nicely during pandemic conditions. Counter guys were super nice and helpful. Jimmy came around to confirm our food was good and see if we had any questions. The pizza was DELICIOUS - had one pepperoni and one Buffalo chicken slice. You could SMELL the spice in the sauce before you even tasted it - and that first bite was excellent. Flavor bursts with each bite and just an enjoyable slice with fresh ingredients. The sauce was seasoned perfectly, the cheese was fresh and there was a good amount of it. The crust was crunchy and was a little thick (not NY thin and not deep dish thick) but it worked really well. The Buffalo chicken slice had plenty of chicken on it and the Buffalo sauce was strong enough to be enjoyable but not overwhelm the slice. (Nice job striking that balance.) A great experience located right across the street from the Morristown NJT train station. If you're commuting, it's definitely worth it to stroll over and get a slice, or better yet, grab a whole pie for dinner! (The family...

I don’t ever write reviews but I have to for this place. My husband and I regularly get takeout from here. I’m sure this is a great place to eat in but takeout is the worst. I ordered a cold sandwich, the bread was SO stale I could barely tear it off with my teeth. By the time I ate half of it my jaw was aching lol. Everytime I order something new cause I think to myself “maybe I just ordered the wrong thing”, but I’ve tried just about every pasta and have ordered chicken and eggplant parm and have been heavily disappointed. I always ask myself “where’s the flavor in this” because there’s literally none. I’ve ordered wings, jalepeno popper fries... all of it was soggy and cold. The only thing that was good that I got here was the clams appetizers. Pizza is OKAY. The menu is huge which is already a bad first impression. I know that most of this food is frozen and rarely fresh. For an Italian restaurant it’s horrible and I like dominoes. There’s so many other better places to order. I would get Fiamma’s instead. The only reason I will eat here is because my husband likes it so I guess...