John's Best Pizza Restaurant | New Milford — Restaurant in New Milford

I have yet to sit down and eat a meal here, only bcuz I always order pizza, salad, and occasionally some bbq wings. The atmosphere inside looks very cozy and comfortable. I'll be sure to have a sit down one day. John's House Special pizza is amazing. As a Greek pizza lover, John's Best is the ONLY substitute for what I'd rather have. Full of the flavor combinations I like, and just the right cook time for a House Special.

I do have one not so positive comment, and that's bout the salad. Vegetables, fresh! Portion for the price, excellent! I can do without the puddle of water that pools in the bottom of the container. If I can remember to drain the water before I mix the salad then my croutons won't get soggy. 😆 I'm willing to meet John's halfway on this topic bcuz everything else is...

I’m going to give a 3 just because this is my first time ever ordering so I can only give a review based on what I had not the whole menu— but quite honestly I was disappointed to say the least.. I ordered chicken Alfredo although the chicken was good the sauce was terrible almost watery consistency with no flavor of Alfredo to me, I also ordered chicken noodle soup which had no flavor but I mean after some salt and pepper it was really good , they use fresh veggies and chicken so I enjoyed that.. then moving on to my salad I got a Cesar salad which the dressing was also an oily watery consistency where as I prefer a creamy Cesar (and wasn’t bad just would have preferred it to...

Service and restaurant are friendly… when the food comes is a different story. Ordered thru grub hub-philly cheese steak, meatballs, and a slice of cheese pizza. The pizza flowed like a river with all of the cheese and sauce falling off as i pick it up, no hard crust aka spine. Philly cheese steak had no philly(onions and peppers). Meat balls were meh, sauce was the best part. Ive been coming here for years and dont want to stop. Please thoroughly look at the order slips before finishing the order chefs. All love but you guys are...