Cafe by the Girls — Restaurant in New York

Incredible coffee, even better service—thanks to Lupa!

I stopped by this coffee shop on a whim, and I’m so glad I did. The space is beautiful—warm, clean, and full of character without trying too hard. The coffee? Excellent. Rich, well-balanced, and clearly made with care. Every drink I saw come out of the bar looked like something from a specialty magazine.

But what truly made my visit memorable was the service—specifically from Lupa. From the moment I walked in, she was welcoming, attentive, and incredibly knowledgeable. She didn’t just take my order—she made it feel like a personalized experience. I mentioned I wasn’t sure what I was in the mood for, and she asked a few thoughtful questions before recommending a drink that turned out to be perfect.

Lupa brings genuine warmth and professionalism to the space, and it’s clear she cares deeply about both the coffee and the people who come in to enjoy it. You don’t often find that kind of energy behind the counter—and it made all the difference.

This spot has officially earned a place in my regular rotation, thanks in large part to Lupa....

I really wanted to like this place: great concept, great location, encouraging reviews. After trying it a few times, though, I keep leaving disappointed. It's shockingly expensive for what you get: $5.60 for a drip coffee that's vastly inferior for to a cup that's a couple dollars cheaper at Brew Memories or Cusp down the street. The pastries and sandwiches are likewise top-dollar. And the vibe inside feels oddly cold and corporate compared to, say, the cozy friendliness of Poetica. I hope they grow...

The food here is not that good, however the coffee was pretty good. I had the eggs benedict with smoke salmon let's just say it had absolute no flavor at all. The service was mid nothing to brag about. The ambiance was absolutely beautiful. I would recommend the owner to move that table by the counter where ppl order at to be moved because no one wants ppl standing behind them staring at them or looking over them. And lastly the music...