Otoro — Restaurant in New York

Decided to go to Otoro on a Sunday night to try some new Japanese food. We ordered the kani salad, bluefin tuna tartare, black cod sear roll, volcano roll, and some beet dish I forget the name of.

We were greeted almost immediately by a girl with curly hair and she took care of us for the night. She was super sweet and attentive, even spent a couple minutes giving us recommendations which we ended up ordering. All her suggestions were great! She suggested the tartare and two rolls. And my friend and I decided to order the kani salad which was dry and unbalanced. It said it comes with a mayo dressing but it was so so dry. And the beet dish was just unassuming, it was decent but maybe just something the both of us didn’t like.

The vibes were good, interior was nice and the tables were nicely set up. Although, my friend and I didn’t have a great time because of the couple next to us. We had ordered some items before and then ordered again after the couple sat down, so I think they assumed they placed their orders first but our food was coming out before theirs. They then spent the next 10 minutes asking every worker to check on their order, even though food takes time to make… regardless if it’s raw or cooked or whatever. Mind you, they ordered 2 minutes before this. The gentleman spent the rest of the night complaining about the service and how the servers are all messing up and how the interior is cheap, etc. My friend and I tried to finish our food asap so we didn’t have to hear this anymore. There’s room of critiquing but the way he was speaking sounded so entitled and it left a bad taste in our mouths.

Another thing, this place is expensive! I don’t know if it’s cause of the neighborhood or where the fish is sourced but most areas in Queens that are the same standard of food that this was, the bill is never over $100. The tab was around $170 without tip. We don’t mind paying for food that’s expensive but the plates were all small and it just didn’t feel...

I’d rate this place a 6/10. The food at Otoro was genuinely great, especially considering it’s kosher sushi—the rolls were fresh, flavorful, and hit the spot in a way that’s hard to find with dietary restrictions. That said, the service was absolutely horrible and really dragged down the whole experience. Right from the start, our server didn’t even greet us properly; he just walked up to the table and bluntly asked, “Are you ready to order?” No hello, no menu explanation, nothing. When he finally took our order, he didn’t give a third of our group a chance to even mention drinks before abruptly walking away—it felt rushed and dismissive. The worst part was the wait: We placed our order around 8:45 PM, but our entrées didn’t arrive until 10:15 PM. That’s over an hour and a half! We flagged the server at 9:45 to check on it, and he said he’d look into it, but it still took another full half hour. When the food finally came, I asked the manager what happened, and he explained that the order somehow didn’t print in the kitchen. Despite this massive mix-up, the manager did try to make it right by promising to comp the entrées. However, when the check arrived, the entrées were still listed, plus an item we ordered but never actually received. The manager was nice about fixing the receipt and even threw in complimentary dessert, which was a thoughtful gesture. All in all, I’d go back only because the food was very good and I live very close by, but I really hope the service improves next time—otherwise, it might not be...

If you’re searching for an unforgettable sushi experience, look no further than Otoro. This gem of a sushi spot delivers some of the freshest, most delicate cuts of fish you’ll find anywhere. Every bite is a testament to the chef’s skill and commitment to quality.

The otoro is the star of the show, melting in your mouth with a buttery texture that’s nothing short of sublime. But beyond that, Otoro’s menu is a showcase of creativity, with beautifully plated nigiri, intricate rolls, and innovative flavor pairings that elevate traditional sushi to new heights.

The ingredients are impeccably fresh, and you can taste the difference in every bite. Whether you’re a sushi purist or someone who enjoys modern twists on classic flavors, Otoro strikes the perfect balance. The ambiance is elegant yet welcoming, making it ideal for both special occasions and casual indulgence.

If you appreciate high-quality sushi crafted with passion and precision, Otoro is a must-visit. Highly...