Mr. Tod's Pies — Restaurant in Newark

Buyer Beware I placed my order for 10 miniature pies on 11/15/2024 for Thanksgiving delivery. They sent me an email stated my order was fulfilled and never sent a tracking number. Thanksgiving came and went and no pies. I emailed twice and went to instagram to contact them. They replied on instagram stating I will be emailed. They emailed me and stated I indeed ordered for Thanksgiving delivery and not only will they refund me but they will send the pies on Monday. They insured me that the pies will be delivered on Tuesday. I waited a week or two and here we are. I had to contact my credit card company and now they are investigating. Obviously, they must be in need of money, so robbing customers is their only option. Save yourself the hassle and look elsewhere. Shady business practices. Today is 12/13/2024 , I will update on how long it takes for my refund. They keep saying I’ll get a refund but...

Absolutely delicious pies, taste just like my mom's and grandmother's and they are superb bakers from the dirty south ;). Would highly recommend Mr. Todd's pies especially the chocolate pecan pie, the coconut custard pie and the Key Lime pie. Aside from all of the above is Mr. Todd's warmest customer service very personable. Would also recommend their Brunch every other Saturday. I've had their chicken and waffles. Chicken was fried just right moist & crispy.Also had their fish and grits. The gluten free grits are to die for!! Great Brunch. !! My hat goes out to...

We found Tod’s while watching Shark Tank. Being from Chicago I’m pretty partial to Eli’s Cheesecake, but the sight of Tod’s cheesecake gave me the urge to try something else. Mr Tod’s is far better cheesecake than Eli’s, they use quality ingredients. I was a bit skeptical of having cheesecake shipped from New Jersey, but when it arrived it was very fresh. As long as Tod’s will keep shipping I will never buy Eli’s again! Additionally the website is very easy to use and they have great...