Fifth Street Bagelry
Fifth Street Bagelry things to do, attractions, restaurants, events info and trip planning
Description
Ratings
Posts
LOVED THIS PLACE!! We came to visit pocatello, and I ended coming 3 days in a row due to how much I liked fifth street bagelry! They have soup of the day which was a surprise, however what I was not expecting is how good their soups are!! And they are mainly a bagel place! They gave me bagel bites with were super delicious... which of course, since their bagels are awesome!! I tried their roasted red pepper soup and also their tomato bisque on another day, both 10/10. They have special bagels every day too, plus the ones they have everyday. Partner had huevos bagel with garlic bagel, which he loved, and a peanut butter banana on a cinnamon bagel, which I tried and we both loved. Their cinnamon bagels are to die for. Really cozy and welcoming place. I was born and raised in Maracaibo Venezuela so it was really fun to be the first putting a pin for that location on their map. I did not want to leave from my trip knowing I was not gonna be able to get the yummies everytime I wanted but happy I'm just 3 hours away, and closeish to the hot springs!
AnaAna
10
Very limited parking / 5⭐ bagels / good spot for hanging out or casual dates First of all the food was really good as far as bagels go. You can choose any bread and then the style of bagel you want. You can also choose 3 veggies. They also include a pickle on the side. You HAVE TO try the 7 layer coconut block at least once. It's really sweet and amazing. The service was very friendly and helpful. The parking is very limited. As far as I could tell there were like 5 or 6 spots. Apparently it's super busy between 12 and 1. We went around 3 and there were only a couple people there. The atmosphere is chill, so it would be a good spot to chat with friends or talk with a date.
Ignacio RodríguezIgnacio Rodríguez
30
A group of us stopped here for a bite during breakfast hours. Their whole menu is available all the time. I ordered the Reuben on a Asiago bagel sandwich and it was amazing. It was one of the best Reubens I’ve had, even at step down restaurants. The pastrami is very flavorful. The inside is cool and has a great atmosphere. There is a large mural of triply images that was neat to check out. The place has a homely feel to it. They have coffee available, bagels, breakfast sandwiches, and lunch sandwiches. The bagels are very large. I recommend Fifth Street Bagelry.
Ben MBen M
00
We came here for breakfast on Saturday and the bagels are the best I’ve ever had. They are even better than Einstein bagels, they are so fresh and have great flavor and texture. I ordered the egg Florentine breakfast sandwich on Asiago and it was delicious. We also got a half dozen consisting of the Asiago, blueberry, and cinnamon toast with the strawberry smear and those were all very good. The service was friendly and the restaurant was clean and welcoming.
Sarah RobertsSarah Roberts
30
Very good food and affordable! My sister in law Dan'vi and my daughter took me and my boyfriend here while we were in town visiting, loved the food here... A little hidden gem!
Jennifer Rae AndersonJennifer Rae Anderson
00
Nearby Attractions Of Fifth Street Bagelry
Museum of Clean
Black Swan Inn
Idaho Museum of Natural History
Idaho State University
Pocatello Model Railroad and Historical Society
Idaho State University Climbing Wall

Museum of Clean
4.7
(363)Click for details

Black Swan Inn
4.7
(265)Click for details

Idaho Museum of Natural History
4.2
(105)Click for details

Idaho State University
3.8
(71)Click for details
Nearby Restaurants Of Fifth Street Bagelry
Elmer's Restaurant
Buddy's Italian Restaurant
Olivers Restaurant
Sumisu | Asian Fusion & Sushi
The Yellowstone Restaurant
Portneuf Valley Brewing
Gin Sen
Goody's Deli
Center Street Clubhouse
First National Bar

Elmer's Restaurant
4.5
(1.1K)$$
Click for details

Buddy's Italian Restaurant
4.4
(785)$$
Click for details

Olivers Restaurant
4.3
(624)$
Click for details

Sumisu | Asian Fusion & Sushi
4.5
(332)$$
Click for details
Reviews
- Unable to get your location