Cafe Gemma — Restaurant in Port Orford

Our first and only experience at Cafe Gemma was pretty awful. I'm surprised to read all the good reviews. But I guess any restaurant can have an off night. We were there for 2.5 hours--no appetizers, no dessert--just sitting waiting for entrees. One of the dishes, a chicken parmesan, came out charred black on top (and the chicken was dry). I had an entree salad that was acceptable, but not at all interesting--mostly just lettuce and tomatoes and a few dried slices of chicken. The other two dishes were OK. What really annoyed me about the place is that no one apologized for the very, very long wait for dinner, the burned parmesan, or the fact that one of our meals came 15 minutes after the other three. Yeah, I guess it could just have been a bad night, but we're not going to give Gemma another chance, mainly because they never apologized or tried to make things right. What a shame, since Port Orford doesn't have many dinner options. We've never been impressed with Redfish, but it wasn't as...

As you enter this charming restaurant, you're greeted with a cozy atmosphere and staff that create an unforgettable dining experience that feels both intimate and welcoming.

The menu is focused and authentic. Delicious homemade focaccia bread is served prior to your meal and sets the scene for the appetizers and main course (not to mention wonderful homemade desserts). Cafe Gemma is a top-notch dining experience.

Whether you're a local looking for a taste of Italy or a visitor seeking a memorable dining experience in Port Orford, Cafe Gemma is a must-visit destination that promises to exceed your expectations. Reservations are recommended as the dining room is relatively small and the...

Wonderful food, service, and atmosphere! We had the garlic fettuccine and the chicken Parmesan, which was fantastic; staff were happy to make small adjustments to the orders. Most of the recipes we were told come from the owner’s great grandmother(where the cafe gets is namesake), and I feel she would be proud! We nearly filled up on her exquisite bread alone! Couldn’t help but take two slices of lemon cheesecake home for later.

All in all I would 100% recommend Cafe Gemma’s to any locals, tourists and others who would love a small, but tasty place to...