Red Rover Creamery — Restaurant in Portsmouth

Definitely the worst ice cream experience I have ever had. The store is small and cramped, the ice cream is pricey and they are VERY skimpy on the portions. They have just a couple flavors to choose from and several of them are gross. The salted caramel in particular was icy and freezer burned and tasted sour like expired milk. The pastries are just sitting open on the counter with no barriers or covers whatsoever, right at head level which I’m sure are just colonies for bacteria. The brownies they sell are sticky with the consistency of glue, and taste burnt to the point that it is a chore to choke one down. They have no means to warm them up either, so your brownies or cobbler will always be room temperature. If you want a good ice cream cone, just go to...

Red Rover Creamery in Portsmouth, NH, deserves every bit of its 10/10 rating! From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with the heavenly scent of freshly baked cookies, cakes and treats. The ice cream sandwiches are out-of-this-world delicious, pairing perfectly with their incredible cookies, cakes, and other treats. What sets Red Rover apart is their commitment to using local and seasonal ingredients, ensuring every scoop is bursting with flavor and freshness. It’s evident that each creation is crafted with passion and attention to detail, making every bite a memorable experience. Support local and treat yourself to the magic of Red Rover Creamery—you won’t be...

Red Rover Creamery is exactly what the seacoast area needs! It is not the ice cream shop with unnaturally colored ice cream and flavors that barely resemble any actual food product, but rather, real homemade ice cream! I admittedly come here once per week or grab a pint to have at home.

I appreciate the intentionality around quality ingredients and use of local fruits and seasonally rotating flavors, which is what draws me to Red Rover over any other creamery. My two favorite flavors are anything including local blueberries or strawberries - those ones are...