Sir Pizza of Siler City — Restaurant in Siler City

My family and I went here for the first time today and we were so disappointed. The buffet bar did not stay full, the pizzas were not hot even after they came out on the bar, nor did it have a good selection of pizzas. The pizza taste did not come nowhere near our expectations. Very bland tasting pizza. In our opinion, a couple of regular box pizzas taste much better. The salad bar was pretty tasty and everything on it was fresh. The only thing missing were bacon bits, mushrooms, and sunflower seeds. The broccoli and cheddar soup was also delicious to me. I didn't try the spaghetti. Sweet tea was also pretty good. I was really hoping this place would've provided the taste of pizza that we were craving..we had heard that it was just as good as scratch pizza that used to be in Walmart's shopping area ( that was one of our favorite go to places to eat in the area) but it just didn't come close. I'm not trying to be mean, this is just a personal review of our experience. Depending on your own preference in pizza taste, you may like it. It's worth a try..at least it took care of a...

I liked Sir Pizza. Our server was on top of things and very capable, service was great. I honestly didn't think the food was anything special. There's a variety of pizzas like salads and dessert, which I've never seen and thought was interesting. Their regular dinner pizzas were great on toppings, but I think it was a combination of the crust and sauce that left the whole thing slightly... unimpressive? It's good pizza, don't get me wrong, but like, failed to wow me.

I'm in the minority in my family; my parents LOVE this place and claim it's the best pizza around, driving an hour each way to come here on special occasions. My sister, who tends to be picky, said it was "really good." So maybe something about what I'm used to didn't line up, and that tilted my opinion. Whatever it was, I absolutely recommend this place for the service and abundance of toppings alone. You certainty can't go wrong by picking Sir Pizza over the other chains in...

Tried this spot with my wife and we sampled a few things off the menu to get a good feel for it. The cheese bread with marinara was solid, nicely melted cheese on a thick, Texas toast style base. The standout was definitely the meatball sub. Great flavor, seasoned well, plenty of cheese and sauce, and the bread held up without getting soggy.

Unfortunately, the pizza itself was a letdown. It was very greasy and the dough had a strange, almost sour taste that threw the whole thing off, which is a shame considering it’s a pizza place.

Service was great. Our server was funny, attentive, and polite, even though she mixed up my drink. The atmosphere was charming too, like stepping back in time in the best way.

Overall, not bad, but I’d probably go back for the subs…...