Mario's Pizza Cafè — Restaurant in South Whitehall Township

UPDATE: back for a 3rd time. The hoagie was spot on. Loaded with sweet and hot peppers, pickles, onions, lettuce and tomatoes, salt, papper and vinegar exactly how we ordered it. Damn was it good. I have very mixed feelings. Once, I got the best hoagie I've ever had. It was a while ago. It was loaded with hot and sweet peppers, pickles, onions, lettuce and tomatoes. My Husband and I wanted that hoagie again today. My Husband ordered it in person while I was using the restroom.when I came out, I verified IN FRONT of the guy who took the order and made the hoagie that he got sweet and hot peppers, salt pepper, onions pickles etc. He said yes. While we were Walking out with the hoagie in hand I told my Husband it felt wimpy. Got home and unwrapped it. There were no hot or sweet peppers. I added my own from my fridge. The Hoagie was still very good. But there was no salt or pepper so we had to add that also. Again, it was still good but we definitely should not have had to add our own toppings. I will try it again in the future to see what...

I just ordered from here and I have to say that the food was absolutely terrible. I ordered a deluxe burger and an order of mozzerella sticks. The mozzerella sticks were incredibly rubbery and tasteless. The deluxe burger was only deluxe in name, nothing more. This burger came with the soggy, undercooked French fries that left me feeling as if I'd be better off eating a raw potato. The pickles that came with the burger were incredibly salt and play a good role in ruining the meal. The burger however was the worst of them all. Now when I think deluxe burger I think ketchup, lettuce, tomato, cheese, and mayo. This burger however had none of those. Despite my request for a medium well burger, this well done, rubbery piece of meat was only accompanied by bland bun. When I called to ask what came with the deluxe (just to give them the benefit of the doubt, maybe it was a rough night) sure enough I was told that it only came with fries and pickles. Mario's restaurant will definitely be one establishment I will never be...

28 Oct 2018** Went with a group totaling seven. I had a medium chicken steak calzone, expecting to take half home for a second meal. One other person ordered a small calzone. The other five were done eating their sandwiches/ meals before our calzones even arrived.

The calzone was mostly bread. I had to cut twenty five percent off one end before getting to the ingredients inside. This was the same on both ends of the calzone. This leaves the middle half to actually eat with product other than bread.

The chicken was not seasoned and was in a big lump in the middle. the other ingredients, onions etc., where on either side of the chicken in dense quantities. This was not a properly made calzone, neither mix of ingredients or in flavor.

The bathroom was clean but dark. It appeared they had a twenty five watt, perhaps a forty watt light bulb, in the brown/tan tiled bathroom. It looked like a cave.

The others in our group had sandwiches and I did not ask about the quality...