Brook Street Hot Bagels & Deli — Restaurant in Town of Eastchester

After moving to Westchester 2 years ago, I finally found a real bagel. Westchester is super weak at the bagel game, embarrassingly so, considering this is supposed to be NY. Then I found Brook St. They're about as good as anything you'll find in Brooklyn. Big bagels with a good skin and a chewy center. The rest of the area's bagels are far too dense and too small, mostly overcooked with toppings that remain in the bin, notnon the bagel. At Brook St., you'll get a bagel full of seasonings that haven't fallen off and you'll find consistency. I went here for the first time two weeks ago and I've been back about 7 times since. It's become a problem. I prob didn't eat bagels 7 times in the 2 months prior, because I've been so bummed about how lackluster they are in Westchester. I wish I had found Brook St. sooner. I don't understand why the reviews aren't 4.7 or higher. Even the staff is super nice, quick and attentive. No credit card fees and no BS for using one. Just a great place. The only weird thing is they call an everything bagel a "blizzard." I've decided to...

Man, when I tell you I feel at home coming here.. Every and anytime I visit i'm greeted and feel welcomed. This here is probably one of the best breakfast creations they have OFF menu that they do for me specifically. It's a bacon, egg & cheese on french toast, thats right.. FRENCH TOAST.. can't forget that side of syrup to drizzle over the sandwich itself. When I say "AMAZING", i mean that. The staff is just as amazing as this sandwich was, & for anyone who hasn't tried it.. I highly recommend you try it out. Tell them "Isaiah" sent you, lol.. Shoutout to the staff at Brook Street Hot Bagels & Deli & the manager is a great guy by the way, they work so hard. They deserve this...

This neighborhood deli is packed with character and options. I ordered a classic lox and scallion cream cheese—fresh, briny, and generously portioned. The scallion cream cheese had the perfect tang and herbal kick, complementing the lox beautifully. I also grabbed a cup of their Oreo pudding—rich, sweet, and creamy without being overly heavy. A nostalgic treat done right.

Service was friendly and warm—the staff took time to introduce different menu items and made the experience feel personal. Between the massive chalkboard menus, fresh baked goods, and deli staples, there’s clearly something...